Dan Szymborski FanGraphs Chat - 1/11/16
powered byJotCast
Dan Szymborski
12:15
For any argument, I use the simplest-constructed statistics that makes the point with intellectual honesty.
Money
12:16
Does ZiPS project Musgrove to be the Astros' 3rd best SP next season?
Dan Szymborski
12:16
Haven't finished final Astros ZiPS and this is kinda cheating to ask.
some guy
12:16
DePo leaves baseball for the Cleveland Browns. IYO, is there enough data available in football to help a team make quantum leaps forward? The NFL season is really just a really long, spread out small sample size of 16 games.
Dan Szymborski
12:16
I don't know about quantum leaps, but there's also a lot of opportunity to try new things.
Gus
12:16
Which is more likely? Cleveland winning 95 games this year, or Cleveland winning 75 games this year?
Dan Szymborski
12:17
75, simply because I think they're a few games under 85 or so right now
Mike S.
12:17
Will we see a female international signing this year after no one signed Melissa Mayeux last year?
Dan Szymborski
12:18
We're still a long way from female baseball players, so probably know. Even when it does happen, it'll probably be a niche role. It's simply the reality of genetic differences in physical ability.
carl
12:19
In the past year, the Nats have shunted aside 3 young players for veterans (Roark for Scherzer, Storen for Papelbon and now Taylor for Revere). Are these three isolated instances or is this an organizational strategy of some sort?
Dan Szymborski
12:19
Well, they're in win now mode and in at least two of the cases, the players involved are upgrades. Possibly 3, but I don't want to belabor the point.
Josh
12:20
What do you think of the Dodgers strategy of stockpiling as many high upside injury-risk pitchers as possible? (or do you disagree with that categorization of their strategy?)
Dan Szymborski
12:20
I think that it's more a side effect of getting shut out for the big names than anything.
mtsw
12:20
ZiPS is unsurprisingly out on the Orioles, but it seems like they have a ton of room to improve by adding a cromulent 1B, outfielder and DH. Assuming they get at least average guys for each of those slots is this a team you can squint into being in contention still?
Dan Szymborski
12:20
Not like there's much ability to add players.
So many of the interesting players are gone.
12:21
I know I've said this before, but imagine that the O's sign Chris Davis and pay him $22 million a year, under the offer that was on the table.
12:22
Now the O's are essentially a $140 million team with essentially the same roster as last season, with Kim and Trumbo instead of Chen.
And that team wasn't all that good.
Bork
12:22
In honor of Mr. Chasse will you be doing a chat using only smoke signals?
Dan Szymborski
12:22
If only I could!
mtsw
12:22
JJ Hardy: bounceback candidate or fork receptacle? Disasterous 2015 but easy to believe he can hit again if he's recovered fully.
Dan Szymborski
12:22
Bounceback, but not to previous levels.
Sirras
12:22
ZiPS projects the Mets to have what Eno dubbed "the antithesis of the stars-and-scrubs" method of playing. What are your thoughts on playing a high floor, low ceiling team (in general, not specifically for the 2016 Mets) of position players?
Dan Szymborski
12:22
It depends on the organization.
Sirras
12:22
Gun to your head, why would I put a gun to your head?
Dan Szymborski
12:23
I can think of a number of reasons.
Pete
12:23
HR power in the free agent market right now: slightly underrated, way underrated, or rated just right?
Dan Szymborski
12:23
Rated
Jordan G
12:23
Dandie day, eh?
Dan Szymborski
12:23
It is 17 degrees outside so no
heyzeus
12:23
How do you project the Cardinals' new acquisition, Seung-Hwan Oh? Given the huge haul closers like Kimbrel have netted recently, could the Cardinals move Rosenthal?
Dan Szymborski
12:23
Haven't run it yet.
David
12:23
What’s your biggest amount of money wager on a game?
Dan Szymborski
12:25
Never more than $100. I only bet on games in which I see an opportunity. I prefer longer-term prop bets
RotoLando
12:25
Gorgonzola, the cheese that sounds most like a monster
Crazy Buck Martinez
12:25
Best option for Jays fifth starter? Hutchison/Chavez or stretch out one of Sanchez/Osuna?
Dan Szymborski
12:25
I'd rather go with Sanchez. Most interesting upside.
mtsw
12:25
Zach Britton for Javier Baez or Jorge Soler make sense for both sides? Britton already getting pricey as an arb-eligible closer and is arguably surplus to requirements given the Orioles other bullpen arms.
Dan Szymborski
12:25
Yeah, but Orioles won't do it and I don't really see a compelling need for the Cubs to do it.
Connecting...
Mat
 - 
5:06
-
Does a $19 Puig in an NL only league seem like good value this year?
2
Dislike
Reply
Eric
 - 
7:24
-
Assuming $260 cap, yeah, I think that is a pretty good value.
0
Dislike
Reply
Zach
 - 
5:13
-
What do you think Joe Ross' upside is?
1
Dislike
Reply
Matt Damon
 - 
5:14
-
MATT. DAMON.
1
Dislike
Reply
Eric
 - 
5:26
-
Do you think Ketel Marte can be a top 12 SS?
1
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
5:55
-
What feature do you feel like OOTP could most improve on? It still feels curiously incomplete for a game that's been around forever.
1
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
5:01
-
Are we still at a point where the Orioles would probably give Chris Davis the 7/150 they reportedly offered or has the market for him (and Upton/Cespedes) deteriorated enough that they'd try and talk Boras down to a more reasonable contract?
0
Dislike
Reply
nickh93
 - 
5:03
-
What are your thoughts on a pair of 2nd year lefties. Eddy Rodriguez for Boston and Carlos Rondon for Chicago
0
Dislike
Reply
JBoyle
 - 
5:04
-
Are the Mets squandering this year of cheap, overpowering starting pitching by not adding another formidable bat/Bullpen arm? They seem so close to being a complete roster.
0
Dislike
Reply
Bork
 - 
5:04
-
What kind of payday do you think Bautista and EE are going to be receiving?
0
Dislike
Reply
Ctwink
 - 
5:04
-
The ZIPS projection for the Twins looks pretty bad on the pitching side and management has been sitting on their hands all winter. Should I be concerned that MN is due for a major drop off after doing surprisingly well last season?
0
Dislike
Reply
Michael
 - 
5:05
-
Hey Dan - how does ZIPS feel about Ender Inciarte?
0
Dislike
Reply
MikeMilligan
 - 
5:06
-
So now that the Dodgers have a surplus of starters does it make sense to package one with prospects in a deal for a high end bullpen arm ? Is it legal to trade Anderson ?
0
Dislike
Reply
Phil
 - 
5:06
-
Valuewise; Dickey and Thole for Melancon and Stewart? Close in value?
0
Dislike
Reply
Scott
 - 
5:10
-
Do you think Cespedes and/or Upton settle for 1 year deals?
0
Dislike
Reply
josh
 - 
5:11
-
can LA clear up their OF log jam w/o trading Puig or cutting Guerro
0
Dislike
Reply
The Cincinnati Kid
 - 
5:11
-
Is there a projected stat in Zips that you feel is close to 100% accurate; is there another that you feel like you haven't quite cracked?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
5:12
-
In a dynasty league, I traded Abreu for Grienke (equal contracts) and also gave up Grandal as a minor leaguer, and a #15 minor league draft pick and got back a #10 minor league pick. I have Hosmer as a 1B now, and my rotation is Waino, Greinke, Stroman, McCullers, Ventura. Did I do good?
0
Dislike
Reply
John
 - 
5:14
-
How do you think Cespy and Upton markets play out?
0
Dislike
Reply
Zach
 - 
5:15
-
Hey Dan, what do you think Joe Ross' upside is?
0
Dislike
Reply
Cruz
 - 
5:16
-
Tommy Pham....underrated dynasty asset?
0
Dislike
Reply
Jake
 - 
5:16
-
Hi Dan, thanks as always for your time. What the hell is going on with Upton? This isn't Kendrys Morales here
0
Dislike
Reply
NCAA argument
 - 
5:16
-
You explicitly agreed to give up your rights for money in exchange for program where you get food, shelter, and education while learning a trade while following certain rules. If you don't agree with that exchange, you can go play in the minors/Canadian football league/D or Euro League for money.
0
Dislike
Reply
Scott Bakula
 - 
5:17
-
did someone say quantum leap?
0
Dislike
Reply
Sirras
 - 
5:19
-
Mets need a bullpen piece, or so it seems. Are there any deals you think the Mets still should make at this juncture? If they weren't in on Oh, seems like an odd choice.
0
Dislike
Reply
Joe
 - 
5:21
-
Where do you see J. Upton signing with ? And how much ?
0
Dislike
Reply
The Cincinnati Kid
 - 
5:21
-
When some of these FAs start signing (and getting rid of the logjam), do you think we'll start seeing a few more trades or are we basically done with mid/major level names until July?
0
Dislike
Reply
RotoLando
 - 
5:22
-
Can Mikie Mahtook be a decent 4th OF this year, and maybe work his way up to OF3?
0
Dislike
Reply
Alex
 - 
5:23
-
Degrom or Harvey ?
0
Dislike
Reply
Tommy
 - 
5:23
-
Which is the hardest for Zips to accurately measure: grit, 5 tools, pluck, or looking like a baseball player?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
5:24
-
Benintendi for Teheran...Who says no?
0
Dislike
Reply
Chass
 - 
5:25
-
Gun to your head because YOU'RE A FILTHY NERDY TWITTERER WHO DONT KNOW BOUT BASEBALL BACK IN MY DAY YOU WOULDNT LAST A DAY IN MY DAY WITH US OLD BASEBALL GENIUSES WHO DONT NEED NO NEW AGE LASERSABERNERDS.
0
Dislike
Reply
John N. Braca III
 - 
5:26
-
What do the Jays do with Osuna now?
0
Dislike
Reply
Gary
 - 
5:27
-
The Mets ZIPs projections look really good!
0
Dislike
Reply
Man In White
 - 
5:30
-
Favorite in the AL East in your opinion: Red Sox or Jays?
0
Dislike
Reply
Mark
 - 
5:32
-
Have Zips for Seung Hwan Oh aka The Stone Buddha aka The Final Boss?
0
Dislike
Reply
Nick
 - 
5:33
-
So the Royals will sign Kennedy?
0
Dislike
Reply
Julio Pepper
 - 
5:33
-
Who's decent first, the Phillies or Braves?
0
Dislike
Reply
Scott Bakula
 - 
5:34
-
shouldn't mike piazza's nickname have been "supreme"? i feel like that writes itself but it never caught on.
0
Dislike
Reply
Jeet
 - 
5:36
-
Hey Dan why does it seem that everyone is depressing expectations on Schwarber this year? Do you think he will have a sophomore slump or can we expect 30-35 HRs with a 260/270 BA?
0
Dislike
Reply
Money
 - 
5:37
-
How is Kennedy not better than Gallardo? And the difference between him and Chen is negligible at most
0
Dislike
Reply
TKDC
 - 
5:38
-
Is giving token votes to guys like Mike Sweeney better, worse, or the same as filling in fewer than 10 names?
0
Dislike
Reply
Steve-O
 - 
5:39
-
I think ESPN/MLB has ruined Opening Day with Sunday games. WTF is going on there?
0
Dislike
Reply
Caveman Jones
 - 
5:39
-
Who do you think is the most likely to win the AL East?
0
Dislike
Reply
Tim O.
 - 
5:41
-
If you and Alderson switched jobs - would you rather have De Aza, Walker, Cabrera as currently constructed I (with Flores as backup and Herrera in minors) or Span and O'Day for 3 years each (with Niese on team, Flores at SS, and Herrera at 2nd)?
0
Dislike
Reply
RotoLando
 - 
5:41
-
Did you do the Padres ZiPS already? What's the projection for Jabari Blash?
0
Dislike
Reply
PS
 - 
5:43
-
What caliber of SP could Brett Gardner actual return in a trade?
0
Dislike
Reply
cmg8462
 - 
5:43
-
Anything specific you look at when finalizing a teams ZiPS? Or at the point you publish are you already familiar with the nuances of the key players on each team?
0
Dislike
Reply
Gus
 - 
5:43
-
Give me an AL Cy Young sleeper candidate
0
Dislike
Reply
Tim O.
 - 
5:44
-
Is Rey Luke's Daughter? Leia's daughter? or Obi Wan's daughter?
0
Dislike
Reply
jtt
 - 
5:45
-
Considering how short the average job tenure is for a team GM, why does anyone stockpile prospects anymore? I'd go for it, trade everybody. if you don't win in 3 years you're probably going to get shitcanned anyway. Not saying its the right way to build a team but I'm trying to keep a job here...
0
Dislike
Reply
Tim O.
 - 
5:47
-
Where in the projections would I find TWTW? (the will to win) or even wTWTW?
0
Dislike
Reply
TimeMachineInTheShop
 - 
5:47
-
Quick! Who's winning the 2020 World Series?
0
Dislike
Reply
jeff
 - 
5:47
-
When using these tools to project a players upcoming season, how much does ballpark, and roster alignment factor into projecting a player?
0
Dislike
Reply
Tim O.
 - 
5:47
-
GREEDY!? ZiPS clearly isn't factoring in his grandfather.
0
Dislike
Reply
Biscuit
 - 
5:47
-
Does Brandon Nimmo figure in the Mets plans this year? What do you think his near and longterm impact will be?
0
Dislike
Reply
TKDC
 - 
5:48
-
We know Bonds and Clemens are being punished for being associated with PEDs, but is it possible some other guys, like Bagwell, are being punished for different, equally (or more) stupid reasons?
0
Dislike
Reply
DAMN!
 - 
5:48
-
Dan Szymborski: *I'm* probably in the top third of coolness among writers
0
Dislike
Reply
Joe
 - 
5:49
-
Mark Melancon for Brett Anderson, straight up (with some potential salary adjusting moves added in)? Thoughts?
0
Dislike
Reply
Guest
 - 
5:50
-
Can Edgar help Zunino stop hacking at everything?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
5:51
-
If you had a time machine, what would be more important for you to do first - travel through time to the end of spring training so baseball season would start, or travel ahead to Wednesday to find out the winning powerball numbers?
0
Dislike
Reply
Curtis
 - 
5:51
-
Any thoughts on Corey Knebel?
0
Dislike
Reply
Jimmy
 - 
5:51
-
Over under how many dodgers SPs miss at least one start due to injury? 4/5/6/a lot?
0
Dislike
Reply
Curtis
 - 
5:52
-
can Tylor Duffey stick in the Minnesota rotation?
0
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
5:56
-
Think Tetsuto Yamada would get the full $20M posting fee if he were posted today, or does "Japanese infielder" still freak people out too much? If you were a GM would you roll the dice?
0
Dislike
Reply
TommyLasordid
 - 
5:56
-
NL West test: Rank the six new starters in order for career value going forward: Greinke, Miller, Cueto, Shark, Kazmir, Maeta.
0
Dislike
Reply
Isaac
 - 
5:57
-
Does Bautista post elite numbers once again in 2016? Age getting up there, but showing no signs of slowing down. Is another 35 HR 100 RBI season feasible with upwards of 95/100 BB's?
0
Dislike
Reply
Julio Pepper
 - 
5:57
-
Do you think we've seen Francisco Lindor's best offensive season?
0
Dislike
Reply
Ringo
 - 
6:00
-
Lester Bangs would be proud of you Dan.
0
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
6:00
-
Speaking of weird stats, Adrian Beltre was worth over 5 runs in UBR (non steals, non DP baserunning metric) in 2015. No one else is above 4.3. Can one not predict baseball or what?
0
Dislike
Reply
Mark
 - 
6:01
-
ZiPs projection your Grandson to get 3 WAR?
0
Dislike
Reply
Ryan
 - 
6:01
-
Do you ever do an estimate to actual on ZiPS? Just wondering how accurate or inaccurate ZiPS has been over the last few years.
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
6:01
-
I was looking at Chipper Jones' career numbers the other day...Will there ever be another switch hitter like him? He basically had two separate peaks nearly ten years apart. Had he not been injured so frequently in the early 2000s he would have been a .300/.400/.500 (which he was anyway) guy with 500 home runs. If anyone should get 100% on the first ballot it's him, right?
0
Dislike
Reply
Ringo
 - 
6:02
-
0
Dislike
Reply
Slew
 - 
6:02
-
0
Dislike
Reply
Sean
 - 
6:03
-
If you could find someone to work with you and program ZiPS into something cleaner (more efficient?), would you do it?
0
Dislike
Reply
Bork
 - 
6:04
-
Come on man ZiPS should be done using visual basic in excel.
0
Dislike
Reply
Slew
 - 
6:04
-
What should the Indians do this offseason? Or is it too late?
0
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
6:05
-
What do you think is a fair back-of-the-envelope adjustment to make to confirmed steroids' guys numbers when considering their place in history or HoF? I think "throw out their two best age 30+ seasons" seems pretty fair given what we know about the efficacy of available PEDs. Or should there be no adjustment applied to their stats at all?
0
Dislike
Reply
Sean
 - 
6:06
-
As soon as next year, does your gut say Carlos Rodon's command and control will improve enough to be a long term #2/3 starter?
0
Dislike
Reply
Bork
 - 
6:07
-
There's enough nerds on FG that would do the ZiPS program just to have access to the ZiPS early.
0
Dislike
Reply
JP
 - 
6:08
-
I couldn't find the ZIPS for Inciarte. Will we get an update?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
6:09
-
Who is David Bowtie any way?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
6:10
-
Have you ever thought of renaming ZiPS to BuTTONS?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
6:11
-
Roy Oswalt isn't that funny.
0
Dislike
Reply
Eric
 - 
6:11
-
If the Dodgers run relatively strict platoons at 2B (Hernandez, Utley) and LF (Ethier, Van Slyke), can your ZiPS splits tell us what combined production to expect from those spots?
0
Dislike
Reply
Matt
 - 
6:13
-
Over the last year the Braves have acquired some of the best names in baseball. Rank these Braves acquisitions/players by name awesomeness: Dansby Swanson, Ozzie Albies, Touki Toussaint, Sean Newcomb, Ender Inciarte, Mallex Smith. Go!
0
Dislike
Reply
joe
 - 
6:21
-
Eiland may have gotten volquez to not suck, but one could argue he did the opposite for AJ burnett
0
Dislike
Reply
Guest
 - 
6:25
-
What six parks are they?
0
Dislike
Reply
mtsw
 - 
6:26
-
What reaction would you predict from the public if the NCAA football players in the national championship game went on strike to demand college athletes be paid?
0
Dislike
Reply
Kylo Ren
 - 
6:27
-
Is the MLB logo left handed or right handed?
0
Dislike
Reply
Pete
 - 
6:28
-
Odds than any current player is bribing umpires on personal dirt like Lenny Dykstra did?
0
Dislike
Reply
Kylo Ren
 - 
6:29
-
lol
0
Dislike
Reply
JP
 - 
6:31
-
All about that base
0
Dislike
Reply
JP
 - 
6:32
-
Who do you think is Rey's father?
0
Dislike
Reply
TKDC
 - 
6:32
-
Yes, but there is no reason to like one and hate the other. It would be like if you like sirloin and hate rib eye.
0
Dislike
Reply
Lawrence
 - 
6:32
-
you the man rock on!!!
0
Dislike
Reply
Lawrence
 - 
6:33
-
ooooooh non baseball!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0
Dislike
Reply