JotCast | FanGraphs After Dark Chat

Prev Page View Full Chat

ann

10:06

you said granderson is much more valuable than bruce? What is he worth then? top 100 guy?

Paul Swydan

10:06

Maybe, but I still wouldn't trade Granderson.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:06

Probably a 45-50 grade guy. I think he stays though

EbenezerBatflip

10:07

Does Chapman get more $/years than EE?

Paul Swydan

10:07

Oooh that's a good one. I'll say yes on the years. Maybe even on the money.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:08

I don't think so, but it could be close

Pete

10:08

Does Yo signing make mets bigger contenders in the east? You think they trade Bruce for a prospect or someone in the major leagues?

Paul Swydan

10:09

I honestly don't think it moves the needle much for them. They already had him, and I don't expect him to be better in the future. But it's still good that they got him back.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:09

I think the Nats are the favorites. Too many questions with the health of the Mets rotation and the offense and defense are probably not league average.

jared

10:10

why isn't Tim Tebow mentioned in Cameron's "Let's Fix the Mets Outfield" logjam piece?

Paul Swydan

10:10

Pure oversight, I'm sure. But be sure to ask him tomorrow!

Jeff Zimmerman

10:10

Tebow is so bad.

Cheeseball

10:10

When he played for the Jays, Eric Thames was an absolute delight to watch. A fallible player who always seemed to be hustling and giving his all. I'm really glad he's getting another shot. What are the odds he can establish himself as an everyday big leaguer?

Paul Swydan

10:11

Given that he just got a three-year deal, you'd have to think they're pretty decent.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:11

I think the odds are decent. Some of the translations look pretty favorable. I know Eno tweeted some out today

Chris

10:11

What does a Sale trade look like? I think Schwarber, Baez, and would make for a compelling deal

Paul Swydan

10:12

As was mentioned earlier, I can't see the Sox trading him across town.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:12

Not happening. The Sox will not trade with the Cubs as stated by their management.

Paul Swydan

10:12

It'd be a PR nightmare.

Rob

10:13

What's your take on the Mariners' trades? It feels like something changed, like DiPoto just got told to make the playoffs next year or else. Neither of these seem like deals a guy with job security would make.

Paul Swydan

10:13

Nah I don't see it that way. Having said that, the Mariners making the playoffs would really be a boost to Dipoto's job security.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:14

I actually like them for helping the MLB team. I have a feeling they were done with Walker.

D Campione!

10:14

Outside of aquiring Chapman or Jansen am I wrong to think the best move the Yankees could make with their money this year is to extend Tanaka and/or Betances?

Paul Swydan

10:14

I don't disagree with this sentiment at all.

10:15

The baller move would be to acquire Chapman AND Jansen. That is, if you're not worried about the fallout over having Chapman, which the Yankees clearly aren't.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:15

I would do neither extension right now. I think their key is to get better talent any way they can

Voodoo bugaloo

10:16

Why does the chat start at 9 when it gets dark at 5?

Paul Swydan

10:16

Because I like to get my kids to bed before we start. :-)

Jeff Zimmerman

10:16

Truth

Danisaman

10:16

Would a trade of Ellsbury+$$ for James Shields make sense? Sox get an actual CF, get out from under Shields, and get a 2-3 win player for like 12-16mm/year while the yankees take a chance on a pitcher who could be as good as a 3 if he bounces back or as bad as a 6 who eats innings and free up a spot for the youth and $$ in the long term.

Paul Swydan

10:17

No. James Shields is warm, crispy toast. He hasn't been good in 2 years.

Jeff Zimmerman

10:18

I think the Sox should get younger and picking up Ellsbury is not the answer

Jaime

10:18

Does Sanchez, Judge, Gregorius, Sheffield, Torres and Frazier get Mike Trout? On the one hand, I feel like that's not enough. But on the other hand, that's literally selling the farm. Trout may truly be untradeable

Paul Swydan

10:18

That's the closest I've seen to an actual good trade offer from a reader for Trout. I can't see the Yankees doing it, but yes, this would be a fair odder at the very least.

10:19

offer

Jeff Zimmerman

10:19

It's getting reasonable. I think only a few teams could actually trade for Trout

Paul Swydan

10:20

Alright everyone, that's going to do it for us. Sorry again I showed up late, but I think it worked out well in the end. Back at it next week!

Jeff Zimmerman

10:20

Bye

Connecting…