Front Office Chat: 11/20/26
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Anthony Franco
3:01
Good afternoon, hope all is well! Busy day for us today, let's get rolling
Blake
3:01
Would it make more sense for Seager to be traded for prospects or MLB ready players?
Anthony Franco
3:02
Ideally you'll get at least some kind of big league relief help back but ultimately, can't afford to be too choosy. They're already going to need to eat some of the deal, very limited number of teams that'd be involved at all
3:03
The primary focus on trading him is to get out from under as much of the money as possible and reallocate it while opening SS for Walcott. The return itself is secondary
MikeD
3:03
I'm guessing the expected non-tender of Trevor Larnach is based on the expected arbitration award of $6.3 million. What do you think he'll get and who are the likely landing spots?
Anthony Franco
3:04
Yeah I was surprised they couldn't find a trade partner. Still think he'll find something close to that in FA, Padres make the most sense to me
I know they love Gavin Sheets as a clubhouse guy but Larnach's a better player
cmac1973
3:04
I'm a Red Sox fan who's seemingly in the minority about Jarren Duran. I hope they keep him. Why do so many others want him gone, especially when Roman Anthony hasn't proven he can make it through a full season?
Anthony Franco
3:05
His season was terrible and paying $11M+ for a guy who's a fourth OF if everyone's healthy doesn't seem advisable. I'm with the majority that it's time to move on
Brewer Fan
3:06
I know this is a pointless question as neither of these extensions will happen but just for fun.. who would it cost more to extend right now, Miz or Skenes? (Ignoring the difference in service time which I know would change the bottom line
Anthony Franco
3:07
Still think the answer's Skenes but it's mostly because of the service time so I don't see why you'd ignore that. Miz is the better pitcher right now, but he's the same age and two years further from FA
MarinersMan
3:07
Am I the only one who really dislikes the Miller trade for the Mariners? Garcia is an excellent defender, but three MLB  arms for a guy who hits the ball on the ground 46.6% of the time for his career and a career xSLG of .391? Miller is at least a back-end starter with mid-rotation upside and Ferrer could be closer material with his GB rates (who the Ms got for one of their top prospects just one year ago). Not to mention eight-figure salaries for the next four years for Garcia, while both Miller and Ferrer are arb-controlled through 2029 and are an estimated cost of $5.5 million for 2027 (RosterResource). That is a massive price tag for an 8th hole hitter/late game defensive replacement, who now takes lackluster career offensive numbers to the most pitcher-friendly park in the league. What do you think?
Anthony Franco
3:08
Yeah I don't hate it or anything but I preferred the Royals end, which seems to be a minority opinion
3:09
More or less for all the reasons you laid out here. I still think Miller's a mid-rotation guy, continue to love Ferrer as a back-end weapon, expect Evans to be a league average starter. Garcia's very good but I see him more as a 3-4 WAR guy than someone you're expecting to get down ballot MVP votes regularly
3:10
He's drawn up in a lab for what the Mariners wanted in an infield addition this offseason and they couldn't just run it back. Totally get why they did it, but I think it's a little bit of an overpay in a vacuum
Ao
3:10
Thoughts on Wilber Dotel?
Anthony Franco
3:11
Big fan. Think he'll be a multi-inning weapon for Pittsburgh and he's the guy I'd be targeting if I were other teams looking for a controllable starter as opposed to Mlodzinski
MoTork City
3:11
I think Isaac Paredes could be an interesting trade target for the Tigers. He’s a free agent after next season, so he probably won’t cost a ton to bring back. Defense is questionable but he would be a righty bat the team needs. Plus he would help cut down on the strikeouts.
Anthony Franco
3:13
No real pushback. Would ideally like an infield upgrade to have a little more defensive versatility than Paredes, who's basically limited to a corner, but he's a big offensive upgrade over Keith
Arthur Dent
3:13
Do you expect Suzuki to sign before the lock out?  In light of the recent trade to Kansas City, seems like Seiya right handed power would be the perfect piece to complete the Mariners roster puzzle.
Anthony Franco
3:14
Yeah I'd be surprised if he needs to wait post lockout. Agree on the fit and hoping it happens to give me a point in the FA contest
$$
3:14
Do you think the Twins overpaid Gray at his age? Did he take the money as the team is unlikely to take him to meaningful playoff games.
Anthony Franco
3:15
Matched what we thought he'd get coming into the offseason. They know him well, he's still very good, credit to Tom Pohlad for putting his money where his mouth is
3:16
I don't think it's any kind of massive bargain but I don't have any problem with it
RoxTalks
3:16
Really like the Martin deal for the Rockies. Seems like a super low-risk move even with the large salary for Castillo. Not like they were trying to compete with a large payroll for 2027 anyway. If all goes well, Martin could be a solid contributor for the next few years at a controllable price. White Sox also get more payroll flexibility to go after more impact pitching. Really good deal for both?
Anthony Franco
3:17
Yeah makes mutual sense. Not anything I would've seen coming two days ago but after the initial "wait what the hell" to seeing Passan's tweet, it was one of those "yeah totally see where they're both coming from" trades
Darragh pointed out that it could look bad for the White Sox if '27 gets banged, Castillo loses the money, and they gave up Martin to salary dump nothing
3:18
But that's very speculative and ultimately they're probably going to spend that on a better starter than Martin (e.g. Taira, Mahle) before the lockout
Whole process doesn't look great for them -- not ideal to salary dump a player you actively acquired four months ago -- but they're at least not doubling down on the mistake
3:19
Like it for Colorado. They weren't getting a better starter than Martin to sign there as a FA for 2/22 and he's controllable long enough that you could see him as a back-end starter by the time they're more competitive
Jeff
3:19
What Is the Braves next move?  Are they looking more to trade for a SS or SP.  Their history says they will not sign a high price FA.
Anthony Franco
3:20
Need both obviously. Still seems likelier to me that they re-sign Dubón and trade for the starter
Optimistic Giants Fan
3:20
T-Minus 11 days until the transaction freeze. Do you expect things to pick up as that deadline approaches, or do you think many players/front offices will wait until the new CBA is agreed on? (Assuming it is agreed on in time for there to be a season...)
Anthony Franco
3:21
It's already moving at a pretty decent rate. Most of the 2021-22 lockout activity didn't take place until after Thanksgiving
We've had a couple big trades, which always felt a little more likely because the FA class is bad. Skubal certainly seems like he'll come off the board pre-lockout and I imagine we'll get a run on the top outfielders and a handful of the next tiers of starters in the few days before Dec. 1 as well
Mets Man
3:22
Two questions: Who is Darwinzon Hernández? And is he really that good (1.48 era in nearly 50 ip)? Seemed like a really Milwaukee Stearns move.
Anthony Franco
3:22
Ha yeah, pretty taken aback by that one. $4M AAV is nothing for them but I'd have stopped at two years and let him sign elsewhere if someone wanted to go three
TigerFan
3:23
IS Manfred really willing to lose a season over a salary cap? Does he really want that to be his legacy?
Arise, Sir Loin of Beef
3:23
Do you think Rob Manfred feels bad for lying? I don't think anywhere near 70% of fans want a cap. How about a poll?
Just a baseball guy
3:23
Good afternoon Anthony . Manfred cares so much about the fans AF. He tells us all the time. I can’t stand him. Do you think the next season will be affected?
Load More Messages
Connecting…