Front Office NFL Chat
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Sam Robinson
5:01
Hey everyone, let's get started for Week 11!
TD-Machine
5:10
Will a change in play-caller be enough to move the needle for the Cowboys' defense?
Sam Robinson
5:10
Hi TD-Machine, certainly was a good week to have 49ers or Cowboys in your fantasy lineup. As for the real team, yikes. The Jalen Hurts issue should have put Dallas in the driver's seat for the division, talent-wise, but a defense full of higher-end 2026 investments is failing. With what the team added via trade (Porter, Gary), FA (Thompson, an aging Von) and the draft (two firsts), this is a massive disappointment.

Tough look for Christian Parker to be demoted, but the team didn't have much choice. Now we're back to old HCs calling the defense in Dallas, but Pettine has been there barely a month. This reminds of the Eagles demoting Sean Desai for Matt Patricia in 2023. That did not improve matters much, as a collapse ensued.

Dallas' offensive firepower and the vulnerabilities in the NFC East shouldn't require a massive turnaround on defense, so I won't say they're toast. 9 wins should win the East. But pulling a guy out of retirement in-season and asking for a big improvement is unrealistic.
Pete
5:16
Can you make any sense as to why the Titans chose to hang onto Pollard? It is reported that they were offered a 4th round pick-plus.
Sam Robinson
5:16
Hi Pete, I am surprised Pollard is still a Titan. I thought the Colts should have moved Taylor for the 2/5 package, and the Titans -- without Pollard signed in 2027 and the RB pushing 30 -- should have cashed out. I get the "give Cam Ward as much help as possible" narrative, but if we're clinging to a 29-year-old second-tier RB in a contract year, maybe that says something more about the QB's development (or lack thereof) and iffy future.

Pollard has been quietly consistent during a rough Titans period, but this is not exactly an irreplaceable player. I'm doubting the player thrown into the offer you're talking about was too impressive, and the team calculating a fourth-rounder from a contender would have been too low is a worthwhile excuse.

But if it was the Giants or Packers, a mid-fourth-rounder (projecting) would have been enough for me here. Though, I can't complain about Tennessee's deadline much. Great value for Simmons and Hooker.
walterj23
5:24
The Steelers got punched in the mouth Sunday because  they did nothing to address  the CB or WR at the trade deadline . Is there anyone who could help the steelers  in those categories? When is Tyrek Hill do back from injury ?
Sam Robinson
5:24
Hey Walterj...yeah, that was eye-opening. I haven't viewed this Steelers team -- or really any since 2017 -- as a true Super Bowl threat, but it was still shocking to see the Bengals run that wild. Still on decent playoff footing, of course.

Hill COULD be ready by Christmas, but I highly doubt the Steelers go here. Pittsburgh was mentioned as a suitor early last season, but the WR's latest round of domestic violence allegations moved them out of the mix. With a civil jury determining Hill was liable for two counts of battery -- coupled with him being 32 and suffering a severe knee injury -- this market is understandably cold.

If/when the 49ers cut Aiyuk, that should deserve a look from the Steelers, who were the WR's runner-up team if he didn't sign the SF extension. But similar situation there. Hasn't played in two years, suffered a major injury and is now in the historically unreliable category.

PIT designated Pittman and Wilson for return today. They should be back soon. That's something, at least
Mike R
5:32
How foolish is Aidan Hutchinson's injury on a scale of 9 to 10.
Sam Robinson
5:32
Hi Mike, your scale is harshly narrow, but I understand it. Scary sequence. And yeah, for a player who had broken his leg two years ago, he probably should have been more cautious. He means too much to the Lions, though I do think they're in better shape here than when he went down two years ago. Hutch's 7.5 sacks through five games still led that 2024 team (by 3.5!) at season's end. Wonnum, Moore and a health McNeil is far better than the '24 team's options.

The injury showed how lucky teams have to be in order to reach Super Bowls/make deep playoff runs. Be it schedule breaks or overall health, so much good fortune is required. A player tearing an ACL while jumping is ominous, as it could happen to just about anyone.

The NFL didn't exactly cool it on celebrations after the Bill Gramatica incident 20-plus years ago, but Kendrys Morales' walk-off celebration/broken leg influenced how MLB teams celebrate. If only to minimize future freak injuries, I hope NFLers slow down on jumping when it's unnecessary
AFC North
5:40
Do you agree with the Bengals being the likeliest winners in the AFC North? How many other teams from that division will make the playoffs?
Sam Robinson
5:40
Good question...had the Texans held on last week, I would have said two from the North and two from the South. With the Browns 6-4 and Texans 3-6, I can't believe it (based on what I thought of Cleveland's chances in August), but I'll say the North gets three in.

I'm torn here. Houston is more talented, but the team has not shown reliability. Cleveland is streaky and has some ugly losses, and a No. 2 seed seeing Deshaun Watson and Co. in Round 1 would be enticing for the favorite (and somebody's gonna need to take the Texans' traditional 4:30pm Saturday wild-card slot, though the NFC South may be the favorite).

The Texans still have games against the Jags, Steelers and Packers. But the rest of the schedule is manageable. They may need to go 7-1, because of the H2H Browns issue, to get the 7 seed. I don't trust the Browns, but Houston's hole looks too deep.
RoxTalks
5:51
Do You believe Coleman is the future answer in Denver? He’s looked really good in his three games and might be the sole reason they didn’t go after JT (other than his price tag). Thanks!
Sam Robinson
5:51
Hi RoxTalks, I'm a bit hesitant on anointing a player after three games, but I have long viewed Coleman-RJ Harvey as a solid plan from 2027 and beyond. Coleman has looked really impressive. Then again, so did rookie-year Javonte Williams; Phillip Lindsay's first two years are also underrated. Coleman may be a more complete RB than both, but more time is necessary to determine that.

I was not onboard with the Broncos chasing Taylor. Coleman (and Harvey, once he comes back) are a good enough reason not to throw a big trade package at an asset bound to decline soon. Denver has traded a whopping seven first- or second-round picks since 2022 (Russ, Payton, Waddle). George Paton has some good draft finds, and the team needs to preserve its picks to keep building around Nix.

I'll say I'm optimistic on Coleman. He might not even be enough of an underdog to be a DEN RB success story, given the success they've had there (Lindsay, C.J. Anderson and the string of Mike Shanahan guys).
Sam Robinson
5:58
We'll wrap there for today. Enjoy the games this week, and whoa do we have a fun Thanksgiving-week slate
Connecting…