You are viewing the chat in desktop mode. Click here to switch to mobile view.
X
Klawchat 1/28/21
powered byJotCast
Keith Law
2:14
Vizquel's defense was not that good and we know this because the data tell us so. There are otherwise intelligent writers who just won't hear it because they think they know what they saw. Now, this probably becomes immaterial in light of the very serious allegations of domestic violence against him, but before that, I think he was on a path to get in.
Dallas
2:14
Jays signed Marcus Semien to play 2B. Keith, I don't think the Jays think Biggio is as good as you do. Wait, hold on a second ...
Keith Law
2:15
I was actually surprised they didn't sign him for SS with Bichette going to 2B. That would be a hell of a defensive middle infield.
xxx(yyy)
2:15
from a travel standpoint, where have you considered honeymooning? not asking for specific places unless you want to share but regions/countries/events?
Keith Law
2:15
We have a plan but are waiting until it's truly safe to take a long flight somewhere.
Turner
2:15
Thank you for the rankings and the chat. I'm probably overthinking this, but when you describe a player as having good hand acceleration what are you referring to exactly?
Keith Law
2:16
That's for hitters and I'm talking about how fast they can get the bat moving forward from their loaded position.
Will
2:16
Keith, love the chats.  Do you see Deivi Garcia as a top of the rotation SP or will he eventually be relegated to high leverage bullpen because of his frame?
Keith Law
2:16
Not a top of the rotation guy - can't imagine him going 200+ innings and maintaining those K and BB numbers.
Mike
2:16
Due to no MiLB last year, was it harder to do your list? Especially since you couldn’t see guys who were at teams complexes, but didn’t pitch in the majors.
Keith Law
2:16
I answered that in the intro too.
Chris P
2:16
Nick Madrigal had 35 hits and only 3 of those were for extra bases (all doubles). I know this is the type of guy you said he would be, but at what average/obp would say that he needs to stay at to be a viable big leaguer? Or is the total lack of power just too strong?
Keith Law
2:18
If he really hits .340, sure, that's valuable, although even that couldn't get him more than a .376 OBP. But how does this guy become a star? I don't see it, and I don't think he hits .340 forever, especially if pitchers realize they can pitch him anywhere without worry about giving up a homer.
barry
2:18
It seemed like there were a bunch of older players on your list this year - ages 24+. Is this due to the minors not having a season last year or am I just wrong about prospect ages? Also, do you have an age cut off to be considered a prospect? Thanks.
Keith Law
2:18
You are correct. Arozarena and Puk might be the two oldest players ever to make my top 100.
Mike
2:18
Surprised to see Julio Rodriguez so low on your list (I know you pay no mind, but other publications have him higher, some have him above Kelenic) when I know you value potential a little higher than most. Is the hit tool and eye that concerning with him?
Keith Law
2:19
I don't think there is any way to justify Julio over Kelenic. Julio has real hit tool concerns, and he's a corner guy all the way.
Brad
2:20
I just wanted to thank you for an amazing job and wish congratulations to you on your nuptials. Your writing is enjoyed and appreciated in my household.
Keith Law
2:21
Thank you, to all of you who offered best wishes and congratulations. We couldn't be happier.
2:22
That's all for this week but I will chat again once the team reports start running, which is tentatively scheduled for 2/9. I also joined Eric Longenhagen on the Fangraphs Audio podcast, running Friday 1/29. Thank you all for the kind words and for reading. Stay safe.
Connecting…