You are viewing the chat in desktop mode. Click here to switch to mobile view.
X
Klawchat 8/9/18
powered byJotCast
Prev Page View Full Chat Next Page
Keith Law
1:16
They're not. Ask Bert Blyleven.
A big dumb idiot
1:16
Danny Jansen has been raking for 2 seasons now, but I'm unsure of the consensus on his defence. Could you let me know what you've heard?
Keith Law
1:16
Playable.
John
1:16
Royals farm system... Still bad? Terrible? Any names to keep an eye on as potential 'next wave' of talent players?
Keith Law
1:17
Outside of the 2018 draft, it's bottom 2 or 3. They added a huge infusion of moderate-ceiling but high-probability talent, which is kind of what they needed most after some high picks used on prep arms haven't worked out.
James
1:17
In the perpetually ongoing battle to shorten game length, why not limit the number of warm-up pitches? This is done quite effectively in Japan, and honestly, while the time difference isn't going to be significant, it feels like an incredibly low-impact change to make.
Keith Law
1:18
The only warm-up pitches that might affect game length are those thrown by relievers when they enter the game. You could argue that those pitchers should be warmed up already. The rest are largely just filling time during ever-longer commercial breaks.
John
1:18
I've been curious about player development and stolen bases lately. Is there a reason that teams don't have all their prospects running frequently in the minors? Even for slow guys, but especially the fast ones, it seems like it would help them develop better "baserunning intuition" and perfect skills like picking up pitcher moves and sliding, at no real cost. Can always have them tone it down when they get to MLB.
Keith Law
1:18
It hurts the hitters.
G
1:18
I enjoyed today's write-up on prospects, but am mostly interested in your thoughts on Ke'Bryan Hayes. You mention his 3 hard-hit balls--has he made the swing changes necessary for future power?
Keith Law
1:18
I have never had a big problem with his swing. He's just been more of a high-contact guy - and I think the Pirates preach that over power.
Chuck
1:18
What do you make of Seattle's scouting purge? Are those jobs going to be filled?
Keith Law
1:19
That report that they let 10 scouts go was wrong. They did let six scouts go, which still isn't great, but don't you have to get that number right before reporting it? My understanding is that they're not reducing their total number of scouts.
tom
1:19
Hi Keith. Do you think Chris Paddack becomes a #2 starter? Has he developed a 3rd pitch yet or is this a case of him just dominating the lower minors with 2 pitches? His numbers are unreal!
Keith Law
1:20
He doesn't have an average breaking ball and I think that limits his ceiling, although he's really good for a two-pitch guy (it's a 70 CH) and is probably ready for the majors now.
Nick
1:20
Why wouldn’t the Indians try to increase Yandy Diaz’ launch angle? With his approach, exit velo, and defense, he seems like a potential star if he doesn’t hit 60% of his balls on the ground.
Keith Law
1:20
He's always hit the ball hard when I've seen him. Some guys can't make that adjustment or don't want to try.
Kevin w
1:20
Why does our country spend so much on defense when we have no border disputes...couldn’t this money be spent on education, healthcare, and programs like social security?
Keith Law
1:20
Defense spending is never questioned. If you do, then you hate America.
romorr
1:21
There enough J2 talent to justify that Gausman trade if we lose out on Victor Victor?  That inclusion of O'Day is awful right?  A rebuilding team saving 10 million, at the costs of better prospects, is indefensible.
Keith Law
1:21
There's no justifying it even if you get VVM, because the trade only gave you a 'portion' of him. I am assuming ownership ordered Duquette to shave payroll.
tom
1:21
I know he's only 17, but is Wander Franco a guy you see in the majors at 19, like a Juan Soto. What's his power ceiling?
Keith Law
1:21
Yes. 25+ homer guy. I'll be shocked if he is still on the minors on the day he turns 20, barring injury.
Hungry
1:22
I'll keep trying to get this answered...are there any moral issues with cooking shows? I love to watch them, but also can't help but feel bad for the all the wasted food that could be used for better purposes than to watch a judge take a few bites for our entertainment.
Keith Law
1:22
I don't know why you keep asking when I've declined to answer for ... a year? I have no idea what happens to that food. We don't know if it's "wasted" or consumed by the crew or donated. It's an unanswerable question.
Mike
1:22
Bryan Reynolds is getting on base at his career normal level, but he is slugging well below his career norm. Do you attribute that to his hamate bone injury at the beginning of the season? Something more? I know you just saw Altoona, do you think he can be an every day player? Thanks!
Keith Law
1:23
The hamate doesn't help but he's also never shown the same game power in pro ball as he has in BP or in college.
Bryan
1:23
What kind of player is Dereck Rodriguez going forward? Is he just a great story or a legit mid rotation guy for the future?
Keith Law
1:24
Back end starter. Dude's been extremely lucky - 4 HR allowed in 73 innings with his flyball rate isn't going to last.
romorr
1:24
DL Hall should finish the year in A+, he is on fire his last 10 or so starts.  Has he done enough to sneak into the top 100?
Keith Law
1:24
He was mentioned in my midseason prospects update. https://klaw.me/2Nt4SLf
John
1:24
Is Joe Simpson the worst or The. Worst.
Keith Law
1:25
He's had a bad week. He's also taken some shots at me over the years, so perhaps I'll just let his words speak for him.
Nick
1:25
Any potential star position players (regardless of risk) in the Phillies system? They have the pitching but I’m skeptical about their position players.
Keith Law
1:25
I think Ortiz has a star bat but needs a position. 1B might work.
Joules
1:25
Thanks for the chats. What would you be asking for in return for Inciarte?
Keith Law
1:25
It's whatever the market will return. He's surplus now. They missed their ideal window to deal him.
Frank
1:25
Which WAR do you prefer, baseball reference or fangraphs?
Keith Law
1:25
I look at both.
Chris
1:26
Klaw, who is your leader for AL ROY right now. Thanks!
Connecting…