JotCast | Notre Dame Football Live Chat April 24, 2025 | 4/24/2025

Notre Dame Football Live Chat April 24, 2025

powered by

View Full Chat Next Page

This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.

Eric Hansen

2:28

OK, that's going to do it for today. Thanks for all the great questions. We'll be back to do it again sometimes next week, likely Wednesday before we shift into intermittent mode for the late spring and summer.

2:27

Mike, I gave you candidates without a favorite on Ced's question. I'm going to go with Aneyas Williams as my favorite. I think he blends sure-handedness with the ability to improve field position by making people miss.

Mike D from Rochester NY

2:26

Hi, Eric!! I’m going to miss Max Hurleman returning punts, he was so sure handed and gutsy! Come out of spring training, who do you see as the leading punt returner?

Eric Hansen

OK last call for questions.

2:23

Dave, I had to end on an I don't know, but it's not something I've given a lot of thought to yet or talked to anyone about. Off the top of my head, there's a big difference between managing a roster of essentially 10 players and one with 105 or so. What I do think could be beneficial is beefing up the scouting of potential portal players, so that when the portal opens, ND knows who can make it through admissions and who's a fit.

Dave from DC

2:21

Hi Eric, thanks as always for doing the chat. Basketball question for you: with the proliferation of GMs across football programs, do you foresee the Notre Dame hoops teams going in that direction soon?

Eric Hansen

2:21

Hi Martini, and thanks for being here. I need to give you a gentle correction. Both Benjamin Morrison and Xavier Watts are projected as second-rounders. But I think Riley Leonard said it best during ND's CFP run -- culture wins. And so does depth. They matter. But I do think ND had a talented roster, and that doesn't always translate to NFL draft picks. But I like the point you made. ... As far as bias and coverage with draft picks, I hadn't noticed it, but I do think you make a point of some ND players outperforming their draft position, and it's hard to think of many who have underperformed in recent years.

Martini, Tappan, NY

2:18

Eric! Thank you again for doing these chats! You bring a depth of coverage and level-headed perspective that is increasingly rare in today's sports media and is much appreciated. Looking ahead to tonight's NFL draft, it is somewhat stunning that the CFB runner up team has so no projected first or second-round picks, and per your earlier answer, no shoe-in candidates for 2026 either. Can you think of any other schools which achieved as much with so little apparent high-level NFL talent? Maybe I'm just rooting for "our guys" but do you think there is a bias in the NFL (or in the media which covers it) in the way that some of our players are being evaluated? It seems that most recent Irish in the NFL has lived up to or exceeded there expectation as far a production at the next level, especially later round or UNFA picks.

Eric Hansen

2:17

Hi Ced, we saw a little bit of the return work in the spring, but not much. It's something ND won't get really serious about until training camp. And there are some June arrivals who could get auditions, including CB Dallas Golden for instance. In the spring we saw Greathouse, Aneyas Williams and KK Smith working at punt return. We saw Price, Will Pauling, Love and Scrap Richardson at kickoff return. Those groups will likely expand -- Faison for instance -- before they narrow the options. The intrigue is whether to involve Love. Alabama, for instance, had WR Devonta Smith returning punts during his Heisman-winning season. Would you risk doing that with Love on kickoffs/ Interesting debate.

Guest

2:02

ced walker Saginaw Michigan aka sagnasty Saginaw pride who do you see as our kick return and punt return do j. love will get some reps there also god bless this football team here come the irish trust the process the golden standard rally we are nd god country go irish love thee notre dame our mother pray for us

Eric Hansen

2:02

Thanks for mentioning the WBB chat. I was stunned at how much interest we had ... more live chatters/readers than the each of the four football chats leading up to it. We will do one of those again soon.

2:01

That's not to say the playbook itself won't expand as those QBs get deeper into the season and show they're capable of handling it. But to be overly conservative and not throw the ball would play into opposing defenses' hands, I believe. ... As far as Chris Ash, his pattern has been to be aggressive. I'm not sure if he'll be as good as Al Golden at in-game adjustments, but I know Marcus Freeman has a lot of confidence in him to do so and confidence in the assistants around him. (more)

1:59

The transfer portal allows teams to distance themselves more quickly from the previous year's tendencies, but let's go with the 2024 tendencies to make your point. Of the five first opponents ND faces -- Miami, Texas A&M, Purdue, Arkansas, Boise -- only A&M was better against the pass than against the run. And of those five, none had a top 30 pass-efficiency defense and three were 91st or worst nationally. So, would you really want to ignore those glaring weaknesses. If a green QB was that big of a concern, ND would have gone with Angeli (more).

1:56

Hi Tom. I had a great Easter with the grandkids as we continue to stretch our traditions into new territory. Easter pizza and breadsticks!!! I think Mike Denbrock is still finding out what he'd like the offense to look like. Remember, he didn't have the O-line intact for most of the spring, didn't have two key tight ends, no Malachi Fields or Micah Gilbert at WR. What he does know is he has an elite RB corps and one of the five best offensive lines in the nation to work with. But it's not just about easing a new QB in. It's about what do the opponents do well and don't do well. (more)

Tom F, Kennesaw, GA

1:42

Hi Eric, I hope that you had a very Happy Easter with family!!! The portal certainly gets a lot of attention now but my questions for you are about how this year's team will progress from last year???? OC Dembrock is in his second season, but with a green QB so what should we expect on offense?? Lean on the run game early in the season and then as things develop do more passing??? DC Ash is new but there is a lot of talent on that side. Will it take him some time to figure out what he has in game conditions??? How do you think he will do compared to Golden in terms of in-game adjustments??? Thanks so much for WBB Chat. Sorry that I was not able to participate but read the transcript. Coach Ivey has a lot to get done before next season and then as the season progresses. Go Irish!!!!!

Eric Hansen

1:40

John, let me start by saying thanks for the compliment. Then let me go to question No. 2. Yes, I think ND is as close to a national title as it's been in 30-some years. And for the reasons you stated and more — including Marcus Freeman being comfortable among all the seismic changes here and still unfolding -- I think ND will continue to knock on the door. To your first question, I am not wired for those kind of hypotheticals, because if you change those moments, does Ohio State play differently ... more aggressively? What I can say is if Notre Dame stopped OSU on the third-and-11, they'd have the ball down eight with time to score and send the game into overtime. That's a hypothetical I can wrap my head around. Sorry for my limitations. Good question, faulty wiring on my part.

John from Chatham, NJ

1:30

Eric- as usual, you and Tyler are top place to go for all things Irish. 2 questions for you and curious to get your take. 1-In the Ohio State game, it seems the game was “lost” in 2nd quarter with the two drives which were 3 and out. Penalties, snapped ball hitting Evans, they gained minus 5 yards and 1 yard on each drive and took 3 minutes off the clock in total. With OSU scoring in first drive of 3 rd quarter, they were down 28-7 and eventually 31-7. Do you think if ND was able to get SOMETHING going on either drive and take 5-6 minutes off the clock to keep it to reasonable score at halftime they had a chance? 2- It feels ND is as close as they have been since early 90’s. I give a huge amount of the credit to Marcus Freeman AND THE LEARNING CURVE HE IS ON AS IN GAME COACH AND THE FACE OF ND FOOTBALL. He is relatable, genuine, decent, humble person and feels like recruits, media, current players all see the same thing. As you are closer to all of this than we are, how do you see it?

Eric Hansen

1:30

I like Syracuse for Angeli. and I don't think he would have picked the Orange if he and the coaching staff didn't think he could beat out Collins, but good point. He'll still have to compete.

1:29

There's a lot of strong leadership candidates, and yet that's very back burner for me in the spring. Those start to emerge in the spring, getting stronger in the summer and then really come to the forefront at the first puff of adversity in training camp. So, I can throw out some names, but these are not predictions of captains, but Bowen, Shuler, maybe even Botelho on defense ... Wagner, Craig, Love maybe every Greathouse on offense. (more)

1:26

Hi Marie. Thanks for always giving me lots to think about in terms of great questions. Can you believe there were two Maries on the women's basketball chat Monday? It's like two Darrins in the old sitcom Bewitched! To your questions. Lots, lots more blanks to fill in, but barring injury I feel good about this being a team that will qualify for the College Football Playoff or at least be in strong contention for it. Ceiling is tougher, because of the missing pieces I haven't seen, but I would not rule out this team being able to win a playoff game or more. (more)

Marie from Atlanta

1:20

Hi Eric, congratulations on making it to the end of spring practice. I know you have worked so hard these past several months and are looking forward to a little breather. Thanks for doing a great job keeping us all informed. After seeing the team as much as you could this spring, what do you think are the ceiling and floor for this team? Leadership will be very important based on what you saw in the spring can you name some players who showed the potential to be captains, or strong leaders on the field? Finally, what do you think of Angeli‘s choice of Syracuse? Do you think he should have looked at a few more schools and considered somewhere where he would essentially had been guaranteed to be the starter?Do you think he will be able to be out Rickie Collins? As always, thanks so much for hosting the chats. I look forward to them every week.

Eric Hansen

1:20

Hello Roger!! For the first time, I'm not edging my own self toward the ledge, but I am questioning whether the new college sports dynamic is going to change what we love about college sports. The transfer cycle in women's basketball is a great place to start, with tampering, unregulated agents and more than 1,500 players nationally entering the portal before it closed yesterday. And getting rid of walk-ons possibly? I'm all for what's fair and I can live with some changes and last year in college football was the most fun I've had in my career covering a team. And if it would just stay there ... but it won't ... and I have concerns about what it will become.

Roger from Peoria

1:13

Hello Eric!! When you first began your career covering college sports, did you ever anticipate you would also need to cover Anti-Trust litigation? I understand the Judge has issued an Order telling both sides to resolve her concerns about the roster limits (she apparently seeks grandfathered status beyond 105 for those currently on rosters) within 14 days or the entire settlement (much of which involves $$$$$), will not be approved. And, the NCAA continues to lobby Congress for Anti-trust Immunity! I am seriously concerned College Athletics is so changed to the point myself and many others will lose interest. Annual Portal Transfers!! NIL $$$$$!! Can you offer any solace to walk me off the ledge? And GO IRISH!!! Hopefully never "IRISH GONE!?!?

Eric Hansen

1:09

The calculation you have to make as a coach is not just what you see on the field in the moment, but how might the picture change 3 months, 6 months, a year from now. I believe the coaching staff saw a QB in Angeli with a high floor but who also had reached his ceiling. And additional exposure might have resulted in teams being able to figure out to bring to light his limitations. They saw in the other two QBs higher potential, and a timeline that would tap into that potential in the coming season. I hope that makes some sense for you.

1:07

Hi Jack, thanks for your compliments. I think you want to convince me this is a mistake more than you want my opinion on whether not naming Steve as the starter was a mistake. So, I'm trying to figure out the best way to answer your question and give you useful information without making it sound like I'm disrespecting Steve Angeli. From 2009 to 2021, 10 of the starting QBs on those national championship teams were first-year starters. So, other coaches have made similar decisions that worked out. 2. Steve's body of work as a starter is much smaller than either Sam Hartman's or Riley Leonard's. (more)

Jack, Strongsville,Ohio

12:55

Hi Eric. I want to thank you for all your great work with FB and WBB this season. Hopefully for you some R & R is on the near horizon. I would like to ask about Steve Angeli from maybe a different angle. Both you and Tyler have indicated that Carr and Minchey have greater upside than Steve. But Anglei has shown in big situations, the Bowl game after Hartman left and the closing minutes in the first half of the CFP semi final game that he can play. Given that he has all the experience and Marcus Freeman has gone with experienced players in fifth year players Hartman and Leonard in the last 2 years and the fact that the first 7 games in 2025 include Miami, A & M, Boise State, Arkansas, and USC isn't it a big gamble to let Angeli leave and depend on a qb whether Carr or MInchey that has virtually no experience?

Eric Hansen

12:53

Len!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You beat Manny on the exclamation points today. To your question, it's been a long time since I spoke to Adon about Irvington and I don't think we ever talked about it on the context of "why not a Catholic school?" But I do know his dad Don as a standout player at Irvington, and Adon takes A LOT of pride in his hometown and giving back to the youth there. He's got two younger brothers, too, if I'm not mistaken. Coach Smoke, Ashley Pierre, was his HS coach, and he felt like he was in really good hands there too. The kids is driven by big dreams and backing that up with hard work and strong values. Really, really impressive young man.

Len from the Jersey Shore

12:44

Hello Eric!!!!!!!!! Thanks for hosting. First I want to wish the best to Steve Angeli at his new destination. He carried himself with class throughout his time at ND. It seems that his Bergen Catholic connections followed him to Syracuse per your article. I began my ND education in 1975 and learned of the catholic league in the Chicago area for the first time. I never thought that today there would be a NJ state wide catholic league. Just to name a few from ND; Angeli Bergen Catholic, Shumate Don Bosco, Baumann Red Bank Catholic, Lewis Mater Dei, Burress Depaul, Wimbush St Peters. Cross St Joes Montvale etc. Players travel within the state and to the state to get into these programs. Gone for the most part are the days of Brandy Wells coming from Montclair, NJ to ND. Which leads to my question. Adom Shuler stayed in his home town of Irvington. What can you tell us about that decision? Adon is an exciting & driven player. Curious as to what drives him.

Eric Hansen

12:43

Hi Ryan. Let's start with Chris Terek. Given that Chris had a couple of different surgeries on different parts of his body, that would have been a good follow-up question. Shame on us for not thinking of it. But I think he was trying to simply the report by saying Cooper Flanagan was the only player who would not be ready by the start of training camp or the start of the season. So while he did mention several players by name coming back from injury, he did not mention them all -- Jalen Stroman for example. Terek was another. ... As far as Jaiden Ausberry. I think he had a solid spring and he'll be in the rotation, but I think Sneed, Bowen and Viliamu-Asa had stronger surges among the linebackers.

Ryan Frankfort illinois

12:39

Good afternoon Eric how did Jaiden Ashberry look during The spring GO IRISH 🏈🏈🏈☘️☘️☘️ also Freeman didn’t mention Chris Terek Yesterday will he back for camp

Eric Hansen

12:38

Hi Alex. I do not. Offensive line is the anti-rotation position group in that rotating goes counter to the "five sets of eyes as one" principle. The only one I can remember recently was Tommy Kraemer/Robert Hainsey at RT one year. Now what ND would like is to be 10 deep and have a strong replacement at each position if there's an injury/

Alex from Cincinnati

12:36

Hi Eric. Do you think that given the depth on the offensive line that ND will rotate some players into the O-Line rotation like Sullivan Absher or Guerby Lambert?

Eric Hansen

12:36

As far as other transfers vs. Angeli, it's hard to find a comparison. I agree with your sentiments. There will be a lot of Irish fans cheering for him every week except Nov. 22, when Syracuse comes to Notre Dame Stadium.

12:35

Pogo, thank you, and every time I see your name, it makes me smile. With a cool name or nickname like that, you could have sent it in 87 parts, and I would have answered it. Position group strength now or on Aug. 31 when the season starts? Let's go with a happy medium of the start of training camp, where 12 more freshmen, two more transfers and several newly healthy players are added into the mix. I'm going 1. Running backs, 2. Linebackers, 3. O-Line, 4. Corners, 5. Defensive Ends ... all those on the highest tier. Next tier: 6. Safeties, 7. QBs. Next tier after that: 8. Interior D-Line, 9. TEs, 10. WRs. These could move around a bit during camp, especially wide receivers. It's funny last year at this time Linebackers and O-line would have been at or near the bottom. (more)

Pogo from Madison

two questions. First, acknowledging there are some variables yet in play, how would you rate the positions in terms of overall strength. Also, I’m wondering if you’ve ever seen a student athlete leave the football program early with better overall vibes than Steve Angelli. Between getting his degree, his love for ND, his memorable performances, and being a consummate teammate, I can’t think of anyone who transferred who the fans appreciate as much as him. Thanks as always (and sorry this came in 2 parts.).

12:29

As always, appreciate your insights and willingness to host the chats. They can be a beacon of hope on an otherwise dreary workday.

Eric Hansen

12:29

Let me answer your question that you have at the end. This makes sense in so many ways. Angeli leaves and ND has three scholarship quarterbacks, one of whom was playing high school football last fall. He's never going to move up on the wide receiver depth chart. He's earned the respect from his teammates by doing whatever it takes to help the team AS A WALKON. That included playing scout-team QB ahead of the Navy and Army games last season. It's all about depth, not introducing a late competitor to the QB competition.

12:25

Happy Thursday, Kevin! As far as your question ... wait, what? If I didn't know you from your questions in previous chats and emails, this would have been evidence that I need to reinstate the "no drinking" rule. This can't be real ... can it? (more)

Kevin from Calgary

12:15

Happy Thursday, Eric! I can’t believe some of the “sky is falling” commentary some people have posted in light of Marcus Freeman indicating he might add Tyler Buchner to the QB room this fall. From some suggesting the coach doesn’t have confidence in CJ Carr and Kenny Minchey to others believing it will force Minchey into some mythical pre-season transfer portal. Can you offer a sane and sober (thanks goodness at least you adhere to the no drinking policy) explanation as to why this is a good thing for the Irish? As always, thanks for the chats!

Eric Hansen

12:14

Hi Bob. That's not a crazy assumption. ... So 5 and 6. I think Micah Gilbert is the most likely and then it gets tough. I'll go out on a limb and say Elijah Burress, but KK Smith and Cam Williams are in that conversation as well. Cam is the wide card.

Connecting…

Register

Message History

On Off

On Off

On Off

Your current subscriptions

None

Register now to continue managing your subscriptions

E-mail Address	Chat Owner	Status	Remove

Enter your email address to be notified when Eric Hansen hosts a chat