JotCast | Paul Sporer Rotographs Chat | 3/20/2024

Return to

Paul Sporer Rotographs Chat

powered by

Prev Page View Full Chat Next Page

AJ Puk

2:25

Why does no one on Fangraphs believe I can transition to a starter? Is is my injury history?

Paul Sporer

2:27

I'm a recent convert!! The aforementioned Nick Pollack got me on board. I looooved Puke throughout his career and I was just going to pass bc I've been burned in the past, but that's inconsistent w/how I generally operate and Nick exposed that to me which brought me back on board. Like if I'm gonna keep driving the Reynaldo Lopez train, why would I quit Puk when he's actually showing signs of being the guy I loved when he was an Oakland prospect?!

Chooka

2:27

Jackson Holliday for Jarren Duran - straight up

Sorry meant to add - AL only, traditional 5 x 5 - who would you want ?

That deal is only for 2024 - thanks

Paul Sporer

2:28

Being only 2024 makes it MUUUUUCH closer and I think I'm gonna go Duran w/his SB impact

Louis V

2:28

I know he was facing a killer lineup, but I just saw Varland's line from today's start. Did you see any of this? Should I be scared?

Paul Sporer

2:30

Juuuuust started it on replay, but hey, that's what happens when you face the badass Tigers!!!

I doubt I'm going to see anything that's going to take me off him completely. I'll likely look to buy the dip unless we get some news that he was hurt and that's why he stunk up the joint

Jtl

2:30

Why do teams take so long to put guys on the IL?? I don’t think I’ve ever gotten a clear answer to that.

Paul Sporer

2:30

I think it might just be that they don't really have to... and unfortunately, they're unconcerned w/our fantasy teams which is just rude!

Mike

2:35

Does Noelvi Marte’s suspension change the long term outlook for him in your opinion?

Paul Sporer

2:36

Nah, not really. I can't recall too many PED suspensions that really derailed a guy's career and I don't think his prospect status was just because he took PEDs or anything, ya know?

Dk

2:36

You ready to get back on the Tylor Megill roller coaster? He added a cutter and splitter and has a strong k-bb ratio this spring

Paul Sporer

2:36

LOL, yes. I can't quit that son of a gun!

Guest

2:36

Who do you figure gets the MIL saves, and do you think D Williams returns this year?

Paul Sporer

2:37

I've been on the Abner Uribe spec train, but Megill and Payamps are worthy specs, too. It feels kinda wide open right now

Salty

2:37

Bold Prediction - Alex Lange 40+ saves! Think he'll get there unless he walks the park again...

Paul Sporer

2:37

I looove where your head's at and desperately hope you're right bc that will mean good things for my Tiges!

Cubs pen

2:37

How do you see ChC saves getting split? Is Alzolay 22, Neris 8, Meryweather 5, others less than 5 reasonable?

Paul Sporer

2:39

Yeah that makes some sense. Their lack of commitment to Alzo might split it a little more w/a few extra to Neris, but Alzo is still the guy I'm drafting

Fantasy

2:39

Chase Silseth or Martin Perez?

Paul Sporer

2:39

I'm a Silseth guy!

Sabey Sabes

2:39

Saw Ohtani is throwing and might his the field later this year. Where do you think he ends up: OF, 1B, blowing us all away by pulling a Mookie and just filling a hole?

Paul Sporer

2:40

Prob just occasional outings in OF if at all

They won't risk it if he's not 100% good to go. That said, I have zero doubts he can be an elite OFer

Matt

2:40

How do you handle questions of "I know I shouldn't overreact to spring training but I'm thinking about overreacting to spring training?"

Do we, as fans/fantasy players, just need to settle down and relax about ST? What SHOULD we be paying attention to?

Paul Sporer

2:42

Gonna repeat this from earlier in terms of what I generally pay attention to in Spring, especially on a day like today when we're going over an hour and I know not everyone is here the whole time: I generally look at Ks and BBs -- very basic -- but if a guy is doing much better (or worse on the other end, of course) than his normal levels in those categories, it stands out to me. For hitters, Ks and BBs also matter as well as power output and their SB attempts. Even if they aren't always successful, just seeing more volume of attempts can be an indicator they will run more in the coming season. I don't overreact to any of it, though, even when they are performing very well, it's just seasoning on my outlook. I don't move a guy 100 spots or anything. The only thing that facilitates a HUUUGE move is playing time changes

Penguin Power

2:42

cedanne rafaela...fantasy superstar in the making?

Paul Sporer

2:44

Very interesting talent, but not sure he has the skills for fantasy superstardom just yet. I'm intrigued and the PT should be there thanks to glove so I like speculating on him, but unsure if the bat is ready for primetime. Very draftable, though

bostonbosox45

2:44

Am I crazy for liking the Pirates lineup this year and seeing sneaky good potential there? Also, am I crazy for LOVING Suwinski? Only 25 coming off 19 and 26 homer seasons, and hitting at the top of that lineup. If he plays 150 games, Is 35 homers and 20 bags too much to ask?!?!

Paul Sporer

2:45

Not crazy for any of that. I share your interest in the lineup and Suwinski specifically! He was part of my breakout article -- https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/2024-fantasy-hitter-breakouts-sporers-pi... -- I'd like to see him be a bit more aggressive and attack hittable pitches!

Dave

2:45

Ryan Mountcastle just kept falling and falling in a 14 team league I’m in to where I finally drafted him in round 14. The Bat X has him higher than guys like Rizzo and Jose Abreu, but the concern is playing time and health. How do you feel about him this year?

Paul Sporer

2:46

He's a forgotten piece of an excellent lineup and I don't think they're just going to discard him for the next hot prospect. If he's healthy, he's playing. I do worry a bit about the HR output bc of Walltimore, but at his price, he's worth the shot

duran duran

2:46

What's your take on the injury to Jhoan Duran? Still worth a fantasy draft?

Paul Sporer

2:47

Not unless I have like 5+ IL slots. I'm nervous about a moderate oblique. Those bitches linger.

Norbert in Mississauga

2:47

Who is the Tigers 6th SP? Mize or Olson. Mize starting in the minors, to have a regular workload and build up innings, makes the most sense to me. But it is the Tigers.

Paul Sporer

2:48

I see it similarly w/Mize being slowrolled a bit given the team's depth and Mize returning from injury. We shall see. Mize had another strong outing today so just keep tabs and see where they go.

Better Call Paul

2:48

Any hope for Eloy and/or Buxton this year? Both only DH right now, expecting Buxton to quickly become OF eligible and maybe the bat comes back once he’s playing the field? Obviously acquisition cost very low for both, that’s the main reason I’m intrigued

Paul Sporer

2:49

Two guys I've loved in the past both on the outs among the fantasy community which creates an interesting buying opportunity. The UT-only part doesn't deter me too much, unless I have Shohei of course. I'm down to take the discounted shot on either of 'em

2:50

Varland updated: getting nickel & dimed here early on. I know a HR is coming eventually bc I saw it on Twitter, but 3 R and 5 H into this, I'm not really seeing reason for major concern

Connecting…

Your current subscriptions

None

Register now to continue managing your subscriptions

E-mail Address	Chat Owner	Status	Remove

Enter your email address to be notified when Paul Sporer hosts a chat