Christopher Carter's Steelers and Pitt chat: Nov. 16, 2026
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Christopher Carter
1:34
Alright time to chat before McCarthy takes the podium. Let’s get into it.
sbaileyland33
1:34
Do the Steelers know something we don't about Muuuuth? If seems like we (including you) scream for him to get more touches and they just don't do it. QBs, OCs, HCs, have all changed and he still seems like they don't take advantage of his receiving abilities.
Christopher Carter
1:36
Gotta admit, I just don’t get it. Guy gets open. A lot. It just seems like they’re allergic to making him the focus of the offense.
Tommac in Y-Town
1:36
Coach McCarthy stated after the game that the Steeler offense needed to start early. In their second series at 2 and 10, Roger’s throws a pass to Jalen Warren for a 12 yard gain and a first down.  The play however, was negated by an offside penalty on DK Metcalf.  How can a wide receiver (Metcalf) line up offside when he is looking down the line of scrimmage?  The penalty added to a 3 and out possession..
Christopher Carter
1:42
How? Lack of attention to detail is the only answer in that situation. Which is odd because that was not nearly the problem it is this year when he was the team’s best weapon in the passing attack last year.
Pitysburgher in Texas
1:42
Hello Chris- I am impressed so far with Pitt basketball. Chase Foster looks like a keeper. Does Pitt have the NIL money to hold onto a talented kid like this? I haven’t heard too much about the recruiting class for next year. Any insights?
Christopher Carter
1:52
hello! He does look very impressive. I think there has to be an entire reset of the collective understanding of how recruiting works in basketball these days. Pretty sure what they have lined up is a long list of likely transfers and a series of contingency plans. As far as who? Your guess is as good as mine.
1:53
I do think they can keep Foster. They’ve shown they have the money to make a commitment. But the question will be can they do that after he has (what they hope will be) a big year, AND keep a full team with depth.
Tom in Dallas
1:53
Good teams can take a humbling loss in the middle of the season, learn from it and move on.  We get the Eagles this Sunday, and while there are all the stats about the last time the Steelers won in Philly, on paper, as bad as the Eagles have played, we should win this game.  But if we don't win this game, what does that say about the Steelers?  Losing to one of the best offenses on the road is one thing, losing to one of the worst teams in the league would be another.
Christopher Carter
2:02
I don’t think the Steelers are above such a loss because most teams aren’t. The Rams are supposed to be a super team this year and have had some bad losses. But would it waste some of the space they afforded themselves with their strong start? Absolutely. And that might be the worst part. Because the harder opponents are coming.
Mark
2:02
Hello Chris.  Thanks for doing this.  Do you think DK Metcalf is a top 5 receiver?  And by top 5, I mean top 5 on the Steelers.  I have him at number 6 behind Muth, Mt Washington, Bernard, Warren, and Dowdle, with Pittman and Wilson closing fast.  Thanks.
Christopher Carter
2:12
OK, sorry had to check back into the Steelers' facility so things will be speeding back up here.  *cracks knucles*
2:13
LOL. Mark you got me with this question because I thought you were serious with the first question.

I do think Metcalf being a detriment is getting old. It happens once in a while to players. But it's becoming a regular occurrence for him. And that's harder to shake with all the guaranteed money they sunk into him.
Fletch
2:13
Happy Monday, CC.  Thank you for the time and the chat. Last night may have been one of the most complete beatings in league history. I think even the Bengals water boy out performed his opponent. This latest debacle aside, regardless of history and current injury issues, don't they match up pretty well against an ailing Eagles team. PHI can't stop the run and is just average against the pass. PIT can't pass but should be able to run all over them (and hopefully will have a game plan this time built around it). Why do you think McCarthy still hasn't adjusted his offense to run through his best player (Warren) and take advantage of his O-line's best ability. Ego? (either coach's or QB's)? Thanks.
Christopher Carter
2:17
Happy Monday!

What's wild is, I thought McCarthy did that. Because that's how they played for the past month. But then one bye week and it's back to trying to be a version of yourself that you've seen hasn't worked.

I think sometimes you want to try to do different things to work so that you can show opponents you have a varied set of skills and they can't afford to just sell out to take away your best strength.

Kind of like having a really good fastball, but needing a good changeup and a slider to keep hitters from sitting on it.

But if your changeup has been missing the mark and your slider is off that day, you might want to stick with your fastball when you're facing Barry Bonds. Save the attempts to get the off-speed pitches in rhythm against less dangerous batters (or for this analogy, teams like the Eagles).
Maryland Steeler
2:17
Chris, Joe Burrow didn't need a running game and it was obvious but not to PG and the defense.  It did not seem that adjustments were not made to help slow the passing game whether it be zone or man to man.  Would appreciate your thoughts.
Christopher Carter
2:20
I actually think they tried to adjust. Burrow just saw through it. It's why I was saying that this scheme is more about containing explosives and trusting that guys up front will make plays. This isn't a secondary that is going to stand up to offenses with that kind of firepower and shut them down.

This secondary without Porter doesn't have the manpower to go man-to-man with a receiving unit like the Bengals. So, you're limited to zone. Unless your pass rush is killing, zones get picked apart by elite QB play, and that's what they faced.
Unfortunately for them, it's a real limitation they face right now. I think it was masked because they'd only faced Burrow as a good quarterback in the first half of the season and the offense kept pace with him. I think as they play better quarterbacks down this stretch, they're going to get tested more and more.
Fletch
2:21
Love your reviews of the game and think you do a great job at it. As a lay person, I saw very little in adjustments from McCarthy or Graham. Why not run some quick slants to get a pass rhythm going? Seemed to me like Graham stayed in zone most of the night, even when it was clear their pass rush was not going to beat the Bengals O-line. Why not go man, you were getting crushed - at least try a different way to get crushed.  Thanks.
Christopher Carter
2:22
Thanks!

I thought there were some adjustments on defense, but Burrow saw through them.

Offensive I just think this team is not built to play from behind against GOOD teams. They can against an undrafted Jalon Daniels and the Buccaneers. But not against a team like the Bengals. Once they're behind, that team can play at their own pace and you're under more pressure as the Steelers to throw the ball and not lean to the ground game.

Trust me on this, if Graham goes to man, they get toasted even faster.
Seven
2:22
Hi Chris and thanks for your hard work. I expected Burrow to torch the secondary, and the Steelers' feeble passing attack was no surprise, but the way the Bengals dominated both lines was a sad eye opener. How in the world did Burrow have a wide open lane up the middle to throw through all night?
Christopher Carter
2:23
Hello and thank you!

Part of it was just a good part on his end to step up in the pocket. And the Bengals have also invested in their trenches on both sides, so it makes sense they'd get some push back after the way the Steelers won the last time. I do think they had this game circled on their calendar because they wanted their get-back. And man, did they get it.
Sam
2:23
Shouldn't Mt. Washington and Muth play every down?
Christopher Carter
2:24
Sam, I've been pounding the table about that since August. These guys should be out there as much as possible. Give them breathers when they need them. But the tight ends must be a feature with how this team hopes to play.
ArtRooneysWakeUpCall
2:24
I think last night was evidence that the Steelers arent close to being competitive with the best teams in the league.  Same old steelers.  Year after year.
Christopher Carter
2:26
I mean, they did, you know, beat the Bengals this season. I don't think it's that they can't be competitive. But I do think they aren't in the upper tier of the best teams. They have the skillset on their roster to be annoying and pull off an upset if they can play their game. But the best teams have multiple strengths to play to that earn wins. And right now, the Steelers don't have that.
Bubby Brister
2:26
Bet you the Steelers were really missing JOJ
Christopher Carter
2:28
If this is Joey Porter Jr., I actually think they have been all season. They've made it work against bad quarterbacks, but this defense was supposed to be based in press man coverage in a way that would limit the quick pass options teams thought they might have. And that hasn't happened. Graham is working with what he's got and I think he deserves credit for the successes under him so far.

BUT, I do think cornerback has become a major need for them in the next couple of drafts to be in the hunt for a CB1 for the future.
Takoma Tom
2:28
I thought I was watching a Steeler playoff game last night.  When does the insanity end?  This is an average team that beats up on bad teams.  They haven’t been a serious contender in over a decade and I’m being nice.
Christopher Carter
2:29
When will it end? When they get a franchise quarterback again and have a more complete roster. This year they've been building up the OL and DL to be more like the units they've been hoping for. But they still need a QB who can be mobile and sling it, as well as playmakers on the outside of both sides of the ball.
SDWC
2:29
If Mason Heinschel enters the portal, then Kade Bell has to go. He’s on his third year and has shown little ability to construct a game plan to the talent he has to work with. When his philosophy is working, he looks terrific. When he has to adapt for injuries or opponents strengths, he’s lost.
Christopher Carter
2:34
To be fair, who's making it work with a backup QB right now outside of UCLA? (Ironically with Ty Dieffenbach. HA.) The backup QB market is brutal right now in college football because so many QBs transfer as soon as they see they're likely not the starter their next season. And that's no knock on them, because they only get so many years to play and if they see a chance to start and prove they're the guy, they should take it.

For what it's worth, Kade Bell certainly could afford to get some other things going. But as a person who had a press box seat to that Florida State loss, they designed up plenty of easy checkdowns to Ja'Kyrian Turner that Florida State didn't cover and Corey Dailey just didn't see them at all. Just a tough spot all around.
Paul J
2:34
Hi Chris! Seems pretty obvious the decision to stand pat at the trade deadline was a poor one. We don’t have the receivers, it was a matter of time until a good team stacked the box and exposed both that and our poor pass protection. Are Pittman and Wilson coming back anytime soon?
Christopher Carter
2:36
Hello!

See, here's my thing about the trade deadline. Would you prefer that they sell future assets for mid-level rental players just to help a team like this? Or would you rather save those picks for the chance to build for a better future?

I think the latter is always the answer unless you actually have a Super Bowl contender. And I think the Steelers were smart enough to realize that they do not right now.
That Guest Out West
2:38
That injury to Mason looked devastating.  When will we get some info on him?
Christopher Carter
2:38
Maybe today. McCarthy speaks in 22 minutes!
Steven
2:39
Dulac reported that the Steelers did not practice for 10 days! How is that possible when you are about to play the biggest game of the year
Christopher Carter
2:40
Yeahhhhh I do think that was an error in judgement. This team was not good enough to do that. At least have some practices the week fo the bye to work on some things.
Oak in NC
2:40
Please explain #41's situation.  How can a player make 19 tackles in a game, and still be a talking point amongst the fan base as a major liability.  I get it -- he doesn't make enough plays downhill for my taste either.  That said, 19 tackles is 19 tackles.  Where would we have been without those?  It's confusing.  Is it that he & Queen are really too similar and we actually need to choose 1 or the other & pair them with a thumper?  What gives?
Christopher Carter
2:43
I haven't done my fully comprehensive rewatch with all-22 yet (somebody get me some coffee lol). But from what I watched I don't think he was the problem at all last night, nor was Queen. This team got beat in the secondary and up front. The linebackers did what they could to try to hold it together. Not that it worked, but I think the roots of the problems were elsewhere.
Connecting…