Christopher Carter's Steelers and Pitt chat: Nov. 16, 2026
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Jr
2:43
Chris: how many years of eligibility does Mason H have left at Pitt? Thanks!
Christopher Carter
2:43
Three with the new rule!
Lou
2:44
Hey Chris. This is it right? Steelers don’t win this year then TJ Cam Alex Boz. The long time vets aren’t winning a superbowl because even if Allar is great in 2027, no rookie has won a Super Bowl. And by 2028 it will be too late for the vets.
Christopher Carter
2:47
Probably. I didn't go into this year thinking they would stand much of a chance to do that anyway. I saw this as a team that could maybe win 11 games and a playoff game with the right matchup.

They need these leaders to help set up the next generation. Levon Kirkland and Dermontii Dawson didn't win any titles either. Doesn't mean they couldn't help the leaders of tomorrow.
Jimmy Conway
2:47
Hi Chris, I think us Steeler fans should look on the bright side, at least we didn't have to worry about the idiotic goal-line play-calling last night.
Christopher Carter
2:47
HA. Yeah, the DK Metcalf fades weren't needed.
Silent Bob
2:47
Hi Christopher - This game added clarity at least in my own mind. Is this defense historic? They made history Sunday not in the way they intended. Will they win the division? No. Will they be in the playoffs? Unlikely, given the rest of their schedule. If they make the playoffs, will they win a game? No. Are they contenders. They are not. Do you disagree with any of these?
Christopher Carter
2:54
I do think they benefit from their strong start to the season. Even if they lose to the Broncos-Jaguars-Texans, their path to 10 wins could still be smooth wwith wins against the Eagles Panthers and Titans and a split against the Ravens. And I do think 10-7 makes the playoffs again.

Now are the going to win the division? Probably not now. The defense had a historic start with how well they played in the second half of games. But that could turn with the QBs lined up in the second half.
Jeff M.
2:54
Hi CC, For the 2027 draft do you think it has to be a QB in rd 1 or not draft a QB at all? If they don't like anyone available to them early shouldn't they give Allar/Howard a shot. Maybe bring in a vet to round out the room.
Christopher Carter
2:55
Still depends on who's there. Don't force QB if you think that player is a bad QB. Out of the guys who could come out this year, I think there's at least 7-8 who would be better than Allar. So, might be worth a shot. But have to see who comes out.
Mark from Cali
2:55
Hi Chris. Thanks for the chats! I am so confused about the game planning in these games. No Muth or Warren, and this constant need to get Metcalf the ball exposes us against playoff teams. Is this the reason no one was kicking the tires on McCarthy? He is not a rookie coach. Thank you.
Christopher Carter
2:57
Hi and thanks for being here!

Have to admit, it's baffling to me too. I thought they learned their lesson after those first losses. But apparently not. I wonder if some people just saw McCarthy as too old to start something new and the Steelers saw him as the right bridge to keep their rebuild afloat until they get to the promised land and then hire the guy they see as the next coach for a generation.
Guest
2:57
The only way Pitt could win the game against Florida State was to play a field position game and hope for field goals. It was such a ridiculous call to go for it around midfield on 4th and 2 in the second half when they had done absolutely nothing offensively. And they did it twice being down only 3 points. It’s not like Florida Starv
Christopher Carter
2:59
Yeah, that was interesting. After the game, Narduzzi agreed it wasn't the best decision, then indicated that it wasn't what he wanted to do and that "the offense" wanted to go for it and he listened to "them."
3:01
Certainly didn't help. I think the world of analytics has broken the mold on smart decisions in a bad way sometimes. 3rd string QB, good defense, punt.
NY Steel
3:02
How do youthat poorly after a bye?
Christopher Carter
3:02
It's a good question. That broke a 9-year win streak of winning the game after the bye week. Do think there are some questions about the approach to it.
sbaileyland33
3:02
Didn't Chase torch JPJ last year, too?
Christopher Carter
3:03
No. Porter allowed a combined 37 yards across the two games. He was part of the reason Chase spit in Ramsey's face. He wasn't having his way and gets frustrated when that happens.
Tampa Too
3:03
Chris, if the Cowboys do not franchise tag or sign Joey Porter Junior and he becomes a free agent are the Steelers able to bid on his services again?They obviously need help at corner.
Christopher Carter
3:03
I think there's a two-year wait to reacquire a player you traded away, so no.
ArtRooneysWakeUpCall
3:03
Who is a better run franchise over the last 10 years.  
  1. Pirates
  2. Steelers
  3. Penguins
Christopher Carter
3:07
So with this only going back to the year after the Pens won the title, I have to say:

Steelers
Pens
Pirates

Steelers have regularly been in the playoffs and won the division three times in that stretch. Pens have missed the playoffs thrice, and now looking like a fourth time coming up, and have only one their division once. Pirates, well, you know, they're the Pirates.
If you went back to those back-to-back cups, duh, the Pens.
ArtRooneysWakeUpCall
3:07
Chris, do you have any ideas on why TJ Watt struggles in big games of consequence?
Christopher Carter
3:14
So, I don't think this is a thing. He had 3.5 sacks in what was a huge Ravens game in December of 2021 when they won 20-19. He's also had several big games against the Ravens in key moments. Also did so against Burrow and the Bengals with huge turnovers and sacks in 2022, and 2024.

I also think it's worth to point out that he's the only Steeler who -- in a playoff game -- scored a touchdown that either tied the game or took the lead since a quick pass to Brown was taken 50 yards for a score against the Dolphins in the 2016-2017 playoffs. He's shown up, I just think they haven't had much around him.

That Chiefs playoff game they held Mahomes and that offense scoreless for 5 drives and even gave them a 7-0 lead. Problem was the offense had 5 straight punts with it.
Zamo
3:14
When you lose line of scrimmage on both sides, you lose - period.  I’m more upset our offensive line didn’t control their front but not surprised we didn’t get home against their line. Its games like these where losing JPJ will haunt Steeler nation and Omar!  Khan has not made good decisions lately (JPJ and WR room come to mind front and center). Thoughts Chris???
Christopher Carter
3:15
I do think that was alarming. They're supposed to be a lot better than that on both sides. Sometimes you just don't have your night, but man they got beat off the line a lot.

And yeah, I still think letting Porter walk was a mistake. Would've allowed this defense to play a completely different style.
Phil
3:15
Just a concerned thought, Chris. Maybe you ought to cover the Pitt women's volleyball team for awhile to keep from developing some type of exotic Pittsburgh sports disorder that could affect your mood, thinking, writing and behavior esp. before Christmas.
Christopher Carter
3:16
Buddy, I've covered some bad Pitt football AND Pitt basketball teams over the years. I'm fine lol.

Matt Press has done a great job when he's gone. Unfortunately, I only have so much time to work and adding volleyball to my schedule would burn out the candle at both ends even faster than I am these days.
Scott
3:16
Why are wasting time with this fragile 100 year old QB ? It’s very apparent this team is not a contender! Let’s see what we have with the young guns ! After watching last night it needs to happen now
Christopher Carter
3:17
Honestly, do you want to feed those guys to the wolves? Because that's what I think they're sparing them from. With the issues at receiver and everything else going on, I think those QBs might have a fun flash or two, but then ultimately get crushed.

And that would stunt their development. Something you don't want to do. Let them keep learning and get their shot next year.
Ryan
3:18
Chris what do you think about the play of Lew nichols i think he looked good last night when in on offense and on special teams
Christopher Carter
3:19
I thought he did good job getting garbage time yards. But I don't think he should replace Warren or Dowdle. If anything, maybe Wetjen.
3:20
Alright, McCarthy just got to the podium. A lot later than we expected, but we were able to get in some extra questions. Shifting gears to that. Thanks for being here everybody!
Connecting…