You are viewing the chat in desktop mode. Click here to switch to mobile view.
X
ETF.com Live Chat!
powered byJotCast
Dave Nadig
2:59
Good afternoon, and welcome to the ETF.com Live session: Jack Bogle memorial edition.
3:00
You can ask questions below, and ill get to as many as I can in the next half hour or so.
We'll have a transcript up shortly after we're done.  With that, let's get started!!
SM
3:00
Most people are familiar with ETF benefits. In your opinion what are some of the biggest risks/problems associated with ETFs?
Dave Nadig
3:01
Excellent question.  I think the biggest "problem" with ETFs in 2019 is just the sheer variety.  There are SO MANY etfs to pick from.
While most of them have a reason for being -- they're right for someone -- obviously there are a lot of ETFs that just aren't right for some people, and it can be real work to tease that out.
3:02
I mean, just consider SPY (etf.com/spy) -- it has over 160 competitors!
160 funds playing in the large cap U.S. equity playground.
Now, there are some VERY cool funds in there, but there are also a lot of funds that have very specific use cases that aren't going to provide the same kind of returns as just boring old indexed large cap equities.
3:03
So I think the biggest issue is simply due diligence and choice.  Hopefully ETF.com helps there, but it's also a big reason some investors have turned to automated investment platforms (betterment, wealthfront and so on) or model portfolios.
Zeke
3:03
Had you met Jack Bogle?
Dave Nadig
3:03
Hi Zeke (and I'll roll a few Bogle-related questions in to this one:
Anon
3:03
So in light of Bogle passing: was his obsession with low cost investing always an endless good?  Is there such a thing as too low, or maybe too low to care?
Richard Martin
3:04
Was there ever a bigger luminary in this industry than Jack Bogle?
Dave Nadig
3:04
SO, short answer, I had met Mr. Bogle several times, but only really had one big long chat with him.  I wrote about it briefly today:
I saw a thread on twitter recently about "who's our next Bogle" in financial services.
3:05
And honestly< i really don't think we'll ever see one.
Not because he was a saint (despite his nickname) but because his solution -- a mutually-owned company dedicated to simplcity -- is something I have a very hard time imagining happening again in my lifetime.
3:06
And it's worth pointing out -- he was pretty controversial, and not just with Vanguard's competitors.
He was not actually a big supporter of ETFs.  He thought they encouraged people to trade, and really spent a lot of the end of his life being a thorn in the side of the industry -- including at Vanguard!
But that was Bogle -- never playing on anyone elses terms.
Elizabeth
3:06
Between the government shutdown and the Brexit vote failing, is there something I should be doing to my portfolio? Should I actively be trying to change positions at this time or should I just mimic "Saint Jack" and be boring and forget it?
Dave Nadig
3:07
Boy, that's tricky.  I mean, the default answer is that anything you do in RESPONSE to a big externality implies that you are faster/smarter than the market.
Consider the market moves originally around brexit.  If you, say, sold all your UK positions or shorted the pound or whatever 3 days after the vote, you were betting that everyone ELSE who was changing their positions had somehow done it wrong.
3:08
because if your a seller, you believe its going lower, and that the price you get today is somehow "wrong" and should be lower.
That's part of the core message from Bogle's legacy: you have to actually believe the market is wrong to be a price-setter.
Of course, MOST of the market is out there being price setters.
TraderJoe
3:09
I saw your webinar (part of it) on the new Direxion 150/50 ETFs.  Who are these things for? What do you really think of them, now that your not on the webinar with them?
Dave Nadig
3:09
Good segue question!
So, the funds we talked about we also wrote up here:
3:10
I think the funds are "clever" in that they take something investors have long done -- pairs trading -- and bake them into convenient packages.
I think there's something putting a product on the street that is a real "money where your mouth is" tool.
3:11
For instance -- if your an advisor who genuinely believes, for example, that Small Caps are what pull the market out of the slump, these are a REALLY interesting way of making that bet.
Sure, you could just buy iShares Russell 2000 ETF (etf.com/IWM), but these let you do that AND bet on the spread between small caps and large caps.
3:12
All in a beta 1 package that's not outrageoulsy expensive (around 50bps or less for most of them).
Would I like them more at half the price?  Grin.  Sure.
But I think they're actually useful innovations.
Tangent Style
3:12
Do you think there's any risk to the ETF wrapper tax advantage vs mutual fund? And is there any chance we see material ETF penetration of taxable retirement vehicles?
Load More Messages
Connecting…