You are viewing the chat in desktop mode. Click here to switch to mobile view.
X
FanGraphs Dodgers/Giants NLDS Game 5 Chat
powered byJotCast
Prev Page View Full Chat Next Page
TuffyGoeswich
10:23
Bryant striking out in a 5-0 count has to feel bad.
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:24
Eddings thought that was a strike too
Kevin Goldstein
10:24
Crawford reaches 2nd with one out, do the Giants score?
Yup (24.3% | 25 votes)
 
Nope (75.7% | 78 votes)
 
Total Votes: 103
Ttam Nomad
10:25
Not to belabor this but Scherzer gave up two runs before errors/interference
Mike
10:25
Slater’ll get it done
Kevin Goldstein
10:25
QUIT PREDICTING SINGLE AB RESULTS FOLKS. YOU ARE REALLY BAD AT IT. NOBODY IS GOOD AT IT. THAT INCLUDES YOU.
Cam
10:25
Eddings booting the ball away. Clearly on the take. I demand the game be replayed - if the Dodgers lose this farce
Thomas
10:25
Looked like some ump interference on that wild pitch. Maybe makeup for the Bryant AB?
Guest
10:26
Eddings is having entirely too much impact on this inning
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:26
Umpires are the true protagonists of baseball games. Players are just here for the Philosopher-Hero umpires to judge.
Guest
10:27
Does eddings have a dodger shirt under his chest protector?
Kevin Goldstein
10:27
Umpires are sometimes bad. To think that umpires are bad in a way that intentionally favors one team is just silly.
Rich
10:27
Joe West can retire in peace with that comment, Dan
Appa Yip Yip
10:27
Okay but this one time I was watching a game and I was like "this guy's gonna hit a homer" and he did so
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:28
Thomas
10:28
Dan, I unironically agree with that take. Or at least, umps are significant supporting players, hugely important to the workings of the plot of the game. It's why I'm against the robozone.
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:28
And that's four scoreless
CJ
10:28
I'd have never guessed Flores will have such a career when I saw him toiling with the Mets
Kevin Goldstein
10:28
People forget that Flores was one of, if not THE top player in the '07 international class.
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:28
Thanks to commercials, I'm already sick of this movie
Joe West
10:29
Umpires are the last true authority in america
S
10:29
can’t predict an at-bat, can predict a half-inning! way to go pollsters
Kevin Goldstein
10:29
Amen.
TuffyGoeswich
10:30
What is the baseball version of Michael Myers?
Kevin Goldstein
10:30
Jaime Moyer.
Mick
10:30
Can't be disappointed as an umpire fan, they seem to go to the World Series every single year
Floyd
10:30
Can we predict a game though?
Kevin Goldstein
10:30
Not really, no.
AvatarDan Szymborski
10:31
Badly!
That's why I go with probs
GodBlessOurBloops
10:31
Vicente Padilla is my Michael Myers
Alf
10:31
But what if a guy is due?
Kevin Goldstein
10:31
That changes everything!
Fire Ken Tremendous
10:32
Michael Myers is an even Nastier Boy than Randy
Wire Fan
10:32
I predict this game will end eventually.  I have been 100% on that postseason prediction so far.
Mateo
10:32
Some authority figures still matter. I stand and salute when David Appelman or Meg Rowley tell me to do something. That's why I have a FanGraphs ad-free membership and support Effectively Wild on Patreon.
Kevin Goldstein
10:32
Mateo is our player of the game
Rich
10:33
It’s October, all about that big ‘mo, momentum
Matt
10:33
Say it’s 0-0 and Longoria gets on base next inning. Pinch hit webb?
Kevin Goldstein
10:33
I'd rather bunt.
Connecting…