Front Office Chat: 11/20/26
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Anthony Franco
3:23
Just a few of the many Manfred questions in here in response to his comments this week
3:24
Broadly speaking, I just don't care what he or Meyer are saying. It's public relations. I wouldn't expect him to say anything else at this point
3:26
They're each incentivized to exaggerate the strength of their own resolve. That'll be the case throughout the lockout (union will do this too with stuff like "the players have never been stronger in their opposition to a cap"). Until they're facing the actual possibility of lost revenues, their rhetoric and early proposals are just posturing
GinaNcRaysfan
3:26
Hi Anthony, what's next for the Rays after moving Fortes? Is another catcher necessary? Also, would trading DeLuca be a good idea given the lack of quality center field options?
Anthony Franco
3:27
I'd bring in a veteran on a minor league deal with a camp invite to compete with Kenny Piper, but it seems like they want to leave the door open to Caden Bodine breaking in next year
Fortes is a perfectly fine backup but if they were going to push him out for Bodine in June, makes more sense to trade him now than committing $3-4MM to that position and needing to find someone to take it midseason
3:29
No harm in listening on DeLuca -- teams aren't going to take role players like that completely off the table -- but I wouldn't want to move him just for a couple mid-level prospects. If you're getting a reliever you think can pitch toward the back of the bullpen, then sure
I’m not late to the chat guy
3:29
Gorman’s gone now who plays third?
Anthony Franco
3:31
Someone not currently on the roster. Could try to trade for a utility type like bringing Richie Palacios back or one of the Baltimore infielders (Blaze Alexander perhaps)
3:32
Not something I'd invest too heavily in with Jesús Báez on the way but it can't be Jordan and Saggese in the interim
Trout Phishin'
3:32
Bohm's gone now who plays third?
Anthony Franco
3:33
Ha, this one's tougher for me because they should be aiming higher than St. Louis is. Paredes could work there, could try to get Texas to move Josh Jung
Burgh Capologist
3:33
Mlodzinski for Schmitt? Seems like a good match right?
Anthony Franco
3:35
Yeah I saw Steve pushed this in the mailbag this week and find it reasonable. I like Schmitt a little more than Mlodzinski and would want some secondary stuff to balance it out if I were the Giants, but it's a workable framework for me
Guest
3:35
Guardians have to keep Adell, right?  They need power from the right side in the OF.  This might be answered by the time we chat but I'm just saying, they aren't going to get someone better than him in free agency, not for the money.
Anthony Franco
3:36
I'd move on but he's never been my kind of player. They clearly like him more than I do or they wouldn't have traded for him in the first place
3:37
Career .213/.274/.375 line against RHP is pretty bleak though. I don't think signing someone like Ward or Grisham would be that much costlier than Adell's arb projection and I'd rather have either of them
BrewCrewzing
3:38
What kind of interest does Joey Ortiz get in the Shortstop/3B market?  (Just in case the Brewers bring Made up in Spring).  I think KC is looking for a 3B? And several teams have been looking for SS.
Anthony Franco
3:40
Yeah there'd be teams on him. Would make sense as a SS fallback for Atlanta if they don't bring Dubón back. Royals to replace Maikel, sure. A's could use him if they trade Gelof for a starter
3:41
Obviously he's not getting the Garcia return but three years of control over a solid 2-3 WAR, plus defensive infielder could get them a controllable back-end arm
Angels GM
3:41
Everyone is talking about how John Mozeliak and the Angels can't make any significant moves, including making a bid for Sato, Itoh, or Taira.  While I understand the ownership change, I still think they can... that is why they hired Mozeliak, right?  He has been in touch with KSE and no one expects the payroll to go down.  What am I missing?
Anthony Franco
3:43
This shouldn't rule them out on Itoh given his expected price. I have a tougher time seeing it on Sato and Taira because if you're making a $75-100MM+ investment in a player, wouldn't you want to know if your incoming front office thinks they're any good?
My name?
3:43
Louis Robert Jr. to St. Louis! They get him healthy and flip at the deadline. How has this not happened yet? (is it because Robert is, sadly, cooked?)
Burgh Capologist
3:43
Where is Jarren Duran going to end up? I think his defense would be perfect for PNC Park's vast LF.
Anthony Franco
3:43
I like Duran to STL for similar reasons as the Robert idea but sure, the latter wouldn't surprise me
3:44
They've downplayed their odds of going for an outfielder but that doesn't make a ton of sense to me. Nathan Church as a fourth OF is fine, no guarantee Joshua Báez is going to hit
3:45
Bring in someone who can play CF and if Church is outplaying Báez through June, make the switch in LF
MikeD
3:45
If there's a cap, doesn't that give an advantage to no-tax states? How is this addressed in other capped league?
Anthony Franco
3:45
It's not. People just complain about that instead
3:46
At least that's the case in the NHL. There's always a ridiculous amount of hand-wringing when a star player signs in Florida or whatever
3:47
It's not like the income tax thing isn't also an advantage in MLB even in a non-cap system, of course. It just doesn't get the same amount of attention because it's easier to focus on the cap
3:48
If it's not that, it'll be that some cities have better endorsement opportunities or weather or nightlife that push players there
3:49
There are obviously levers you can pull in the CBA to make things more fair, but free agency's just never going to be a completely even playing field. Smaller cities in the Midwest are going to be at some kind of disadvantage on some players
Jaysfansince1977
3:50
Your thoughts on the Jay's possibly landing Skubal, Sato or Lowe.....chances of landing all three of them?? Which one do they need the most???
Anthony Franco
3:50
Can't really see Sato and Lowe but one of the bats and Skubal doesn't seem completely outlandish
Guess I'd order them Lowe, Skubal, Sato in likelihood to end up there
Brewer Fan
3:50
I still think people over rate the cap impact on FA but WILDLY underestimate the impact it has on not letting players get to FA. I've said it many times but the Packers have kept hall of fame caliber QBs, paying them top of the market money in the smallest market in sports. They have retained them until the team decided to part ways. You have any thoughts on that part of it?
Anthony Franco
3:52
Yeah this is definitely a thing, it's built right into the system (i.e. MLB saying that an external FA can account for max 15% of the cap but players re-signing can receive 16%). It's intentional to try to limit player movement
That's a feature for some fans, a bug for others. You still get activity, mostly via trades, but free agency in other sports isn't as impactful as it is in MLB
3:53
It makes it easier for small-market fans to have attachments to one player for longer but probably makes it a little harder to pull out of a rebuild when there are fewer ways out of it beyond draft and develop
Connecting…