Front Office Chat: 11/20/26
powered byJotCast
This chat is available to members only. Please log in to participate.
Anthony Franco
3:54
NFL has the franchise tag on top of that, which is an absurdly anti-player measure that the MLBPA would need to be completely gutted to ever agree to
3:55
And just the fact that a quarterback in football is miles more valuable to a team's success than any individual player is in baseball. It'd be like having Tarik Skubal pitch every game
Sharky
3:55
Yanks getting off to a good start with the pen but there’s still a yawning, gaping chasm at third. Sato seems like the most ‘exciting’ option even if there’s risk there, but yanks don’t seem to be getting a lot of press in connection with him. Will Cashman surprise us or should I get ready to be disappointed with something like Bohm?
Anthony Franco
3:56
Still think Gelof for one of the Yanks' "surplus" starters makes the most sense there
ZacharyA
3:56
Re: the Maikel Garcia trade. When was the last time a team traded a homegrown player less than a year after giving them a multi-year extension? Seems like this type of thing never happens.
Anthony Franco
3:57
Yeah that's a great question. I have no idea
Glasnow's the closest analogue I can think of, but he wasn't technically homegrown for TB and was a year from FA
3:58
Rockies traded Arenado within two years of extending him but it took a falling out between him and the GM
And the GM completely butchering the whole thing and getting nothing in return
Brewer Fan
3:58
Why would it make it harder for small markets in a rebuild? Not like they make a lot of an impact in this system of FA. (Absolutley agree on the Tag, the tag is horrible)
Anthony Franco
3:59
I don't mean that as a small-market thing specifically. I think this is the case for any team that's not good
If you have a bunch of roster holes to fill and the economic system is designed to get players to sign extensions rather than test free agency, just leaves you with fewer options that aren't "draft better players and wait until they're ready"
Will
4:00
Who says no: Padres send: Jake Cronenworth, Kruz Schoolcraft, Luis Campusano, Ryan Wideman, and Ryan Balzer Yankees send: Will Warren, Jasson Dominguez, Elmer Rodríguez
Will
4:00
There has to be a Padres-Yanks deal coming doesn’t there? The two match up too well on a needs basis.
Anthony Franco
4:01
Having a tough time seeing the appeal of this one for NY. I don't think they match up as well as you do, I guess
4:02
Cronenworth's not clearly better than their internal options at 2B. Campusano can hit but they were seemingly out on Tyler Stephenson at the deadline because of the glove and Campusano's probably worse defensively
4:03
Fermin seems more their type as the RHH backup but I wouldn't give up any of their notable starting pitchers for him
Maybe Luis Gil but not Rodriguez or Warren
Dave
4:04
Any way Chapman is dealt to the Yanks or Phils? I know he has a NTC but those things are often dealt with. How much $$ would the Giants have to add to the deal?
Anthony Franco
4:05
I think the season-ending core surgery killed any chance of it happening this offseason. He's got four years left at $25M per for 34-37 coming off that injury
4:06
If he were a free agent this offseason, I'd probably have him around 2/30 ... maybe 35? Couldn't see anyone going beyond two years
4:07
Giants are better served holding him and hoping a healthy first half makes him movable
The Willies of SF
4:07
With the Giants needing to rebuild their bullpen, what do you imagine it will cost (dollars and length) to entice Alex Vesia and Jojo Romero to San Francisco?
Anthony Franco
4:08
I'm at 3/36 on Vesia, got overruled by Steve and Darragh who think he's getting two years (similar AAV though)
4:09
Romero like 2/15. He's alright, don't think he should beat Loáisiga's 18 though
Guest
4:09
What would it take for the Nats to acquire Carmen Mlodzinski from the Pittsburgh Pirates? Are the Nats likely to want to use him as a starter or a swing player?
Anthony Franco
4:10
He'd start for Washington, especially if they're only looking at the Brady Singer/Kona Takahashi types in FA. Seems like they prefer Alvarez and Lord as swing guys
4:11
Brady House challenge trade would be pretty fun
Bendix
4:11
Should I trade away from my depth at the minors and take a big swing for Elly or another superstar? Maybe, a superstar of the franchise will help people come to the stadium? Thoughts?
Anthony Franco
4:13
Can't see the Marlins doing this (nor do I expect the Reds to trade Elly to anyone this offseason). You could sell me on them as a dark horse for trading for Reid Detmers or something, but nothing in the Sherman ownership or Bendix front office tenure suggests that's how they'll operate
4:14
Neto's a Miami guy, could try to put something together and flip Edwards for a controllable starter? Those are about as big as I can even vaguely see them doing though
Just Curious
4:15
Best guess on which team Sato ends up with and what kind of impact?  Thanks!
Anthony Franco
4:16
I'll go Philly as a right fielder but I'm wary of him personally. The swing rate in Japan was high enough to scare me
4:17
He's obviously got huge power but the contact skills aren't good and he doesn't have Murakami's patience as the floor to keep the OBP respectable if he's striking out 30-32% of the time
4:20
Optimistic outcome is that it looks more like Okamoto's offensive numbers year one (albeit as a LHH) with less defensive value. Downside is that the OBP is more in the .290-300 range and it's kind of a power-only profile
Miz
4:20
Ever see the Twilight Zone where alast place team gets a terrific young pitcher who's unhitable. Until he gets hit and they find out he's a robot. The Commish says you can't play if you're not human and you're not human if you don't have a heart. So the doctors give him a heart and ------ he can't bear to strike anyone out. Good episode. Oh, is Miz a robot?
Anthony Franco
4:21
Newest Terminator sequel
4:22
That feels like an appropriate place to wrap it but a bittersweet personal announcement to make on the way out
4:24
This is my final one of these. Next week's my final full-time week at MLBTR and I'm off next Friday for the holiday. Darragh's hoping to pinch hit (subject to not getting crushed with news that day)
4:27
I'm stepping aside on a full-time basis once the lockout goes into effect. All on good terms and everything, hoping to contribute on a part-time basis if the lockout "only" lasts for a few months and there's a transaction rush in mid-March
Connecting…