You are viewing the chat in desktop mode. Click here to switch to mobile view.
X
Jay Jaffe FanGraphs Chat - 5/26/20
powered byJotCast
View Full Chat Next Page
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:02
Good afternoon and welcome to the second edition of my chat in this Tuesday time slot, which thankfully is working better than Monday did in these pandemic-ridden times.
2:05
Before I dive in, a bit of housekeeping: I've been very focussed on the Korea Baseball Organization lately, and at the end of today's piece on Doosan Bears hitting machine Jose Miguel Fernandez (https://blogs.fangraphs.com/doosan-bears-fernandez-is-tearing-up-the-k...) I noted that I'll be a guest on tomorrow's ESPB KBO broadcast. I'll be joining a Bears-SK Wyverns game, talking with hots Jon Sciambi and Eduardo Perez at around 7:30 AM ET. It's my first time being part of a game broadcast, even under theses strange conditions, and it should be a lot of fun. I'll have an Instagraphs post with further details including re-airing times.
Magic Kingdome
2:05
What is your best interaction with a Hall of Fame candidate?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:07
Hmmmm. I haven't had a ton of them that particularly stand out. The first, though, was when I got Willie Mays' autograph, which might have been 1981 or '82. He was appearing at some grocery store expo at the Salt Palace in Salt Lake City, one of several players (Don Sutton was also on the list) but the one that I somehow convinced my mom to take me to. I had a 1973 Topps card of Mays as a Met, a hand-me-down from my cousin Allan. We stood in line, and he autographed the card without even making eye contact; he was bored as hell and didn't care who knew it.
2:08
More fun was my Vin Scully interaction, from 1989 at Vero Beach, which I wrote about as part of a 2016 Sports Illustrated piece (https://www.si.com/mlb/2016/09/30/vin-scully-tribute-dodgers-jay-jaffe). When I was a college freshman, my parents took my brother and me to Dodgertown during my spring break, and I had a chance encounter with the great announcer himself. From the piece
2:10
En route to the concession stand before one ballgame, I crossed paths with Scully himself, decked out in a cream-colored golf sweater. I asked for an autograph, then realized I had just a scrap of paper and no pen. Seeing how flustered I was, he agreed to wait while I fetched one from my mother, who was on her way to the restroom. Somehow, I not only got the pen, but Vin waited in place, and signed what might have been a golf scorecard or a ticket stub. I’ve long since lost that piece of paper—inevitable while moving half a dozen times in four years—and I’ve never gotten to meet Scully again despite being now being armed with a credential. But I’ve never forgotten the man’s small gesture of patience and humanity toward a star-struck 19-year-old.
Mike Tyson: Designated Hitter
2:10
Very curious what you think about the changes in MILB and how that will impact talent development going forward.   Will this ultimately play a role in colleges having an even greater influence in player development closer to what it is in football.  When you are dealing with high school players, will this eliminate all but the very cream of the crop from making the minors.
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:14
Even as somebody who's not very involved in the amateur side of baseball, I can see that this has the potential to be catastrophic for the growth of the sport. Already the pandemic is likely to lead to budget cuts, and the specifics of this season — with the suddenly shortened draft, and college players granted an extra year of eligibility  — is going to create a cluster**** of competition for those precious scholarships. Meanwhile, there will be fewer minor league jobs going forward, and ultimately fewer kids steered towards baseball, and fewer stories of late bloomers who turned into major leaguers, whether or not they become stars. That's the snuffing of dreams, and it's very bad for the sport.
Curtis
2:14
In your opinion, how many HOFers SHOULD have been unanimous?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:16
Maybe two dozen? I can easily get to a dozen just off the top of my head, working chronologically Cobb, Ruth, Cy Young, Walter Johnson, Honus Wagner, Rogers Hornsby, Ted Williams, Jackie Robinson, Stan Musial, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Frank Robinson. And I'm sure there are a dozen more.
olethros
2:16
Have you ever considered adding a standard deviation component to the JAWS system?  I feel like some positions have a much wider variance than others, usually towards the upper end, and it might be useful to have bands rather than a bright line.
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:19
Somewhere I have those numbers, or had them at one point. Not hard to do, and possibly useful, but potentially confusing to some people who don't like to be reminded that they're doing math. I had given some thought to a position-by-position deep dive during pandemic times, and am not opposed to including that as part of the format, but lately my attention has been focused elsewhere.
Alex
2:19
If Statcast measures the longest modern home runs as just barely exceeding 500 feet, is there good reason to believe in reports of >550 footers?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:20
I'm somewhat skeptical about old time home run measurements, though the supreme talents of sluggers like Ruth, Williams, and Mantle attached to those numbers keep me from discounting them entirely.
Magic Kingdome
2:20
Does the owner-MLBPA dispute end if there is a hybrid proposal that players get a certain (high) percentage guarantee of prorated salary in exchange for some share if revenue exceed a certain threshold?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:21
I'm not sure where they'll end up, but I suspect it's some slight or modest discount on the prorated salary in exchange for some concession that may or may not specifically be revenue-related. It's going to take compromise to pull this off.
Todd
2:23
Whatchuthinkabout Jun-Wun Seo, 19 YO sidearmer for the Lotte Giants?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:26
2:28
The league does seem to have a higher complement of sidearmers than MLB, which is very cool. I've noticed in the splits on Statiz (which is difficult to navigate even with Chrome translation turned on) that they distinguish between "orthodox" and "under" (sidearm or submarine). Here's the page of NC Dinos catcher Euiji Yang, for example: http://www.statiz.co.kr/player.php?opt=4&sopt=0&name=%EC%96%91%EC%9D%9...
2:29
Jenny ParticularDots
2:30
Do you have any go-to tiebreakers for determining whether an on-the-fence player should be in the Hall (i.e. peak seasons, historical impact, etc.)?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:31
I'm not sure I can point to a single factor but both of those that you mentioned are important. I tend to favor high-peak guys even if their careers were a bit short (Allen, Munson, Grich, Santo, Halladay). Historical impact should always be considered, and to be honest, it provides a fairly wide latitude for the inclusion of subjective weighting alongside the stats.
One thing
2:32
We had a baby in February, so at the least, we've spent a whole lot of time with him. He is listening to animal sounds now. :)
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:33
I'm not exactly sure what the connection of this is to anything in specific, but congratulations. I know from personal experience that taking care of little ones while juggling work-from-home stuff is a particular challenge, so best of luck to you.
LOL
2:33
So, uh, we may well have Jeter and Schilling together in 2021, huh? Fun crowd.
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:36
perhaps ,but it's not like Jeter was the only member of the Class of 2020. Larry Walker and Ted Simmons are both pretty fascinating guys; the former one of the funniest ballplayers of his time and the latter a particularly cerebral one. I'm not sure what the Hall is going to do in the case of Marvin Miller given his family's insistence on boycotting the proceedings, but any one of a number of Hall of Famers who worked with him in the union and went to free agency could be part of it. Joe Torre comes to mind in particular.

Likewise, there's hope that between the two Era Committees (Early Baseball and Golden Days) there's at least one honoree and perhaps more. Dick Allen, for one, is still alive and came very close last time.
amanontheriver
2:36
I'm incredibly new to the KBO (as are most new KBO fans, I'm guessing), so my eyeballs aren't finely-tuned to see which guys, exactly, could cut it in the bigs. Do you think Dinos lefty Chang-mo Koo could be one of "those guys" who could play in MLB some day, especially since he's only 23?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:41
If I'm reading it right, his average fastball velocity is only about 89 mph, but the strikeout rate and run prevention are impressive enough to suggest a guy who would definitely interest teams.

I'm not a guy whom you should trust for a scouting report, but here's what Baseball America's Kyle Glaser wrote recently (https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/top-10-mlb-prospects-to-know-i...)

He is a soft-tossing lefty who mixes four average pitches and has a chance to add strength and throw harder in the future. Koo's command isn’t as sharp as [KIA lefty Hyeon Jong] Yang’s, but that’s largely a product of experience and could come in time.
Jay d
2:42
If the hall of fame was strictly based on being famous, no consideration towards stars or awards, who would be the biggest names not in the current hall of fame?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:43
If you're putting aside actual eligibility concerns, Pete Rose is certainly up there, as are many other famous players whose transgressions didn't earn them actual bans but have turned off enough voters to stall their election chances: Bonds, Clemens, Manny, A-Rod.
Kolbe
2:44
This might be out of your league (literally) but you are known for measuring greatness. Who's the NBA'S greatest player ever?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:46
If you're talking about relative to the league — as we do with WAR, etc —  I imagine Chamberlain and Russell have their claims because they were so much better than their competition, but the quality of play continues to rise, which should steer the conversation towards a more contemporary player. It still probably boils down to Michael Jordan and LeBron James for the choice of all-time great, and my visceral distaste for Jordan means you should find somebody more objective to answer that question.
Alex
2:47
In order to cause more balls to be put in play (via suppressing bat speed and encouraging a more contact oriented approach), Bill James has suggested--among other things--mandating a minimum bat thickness. If you believe this is a worthy goal, do you have any pet ideas to achieve it?
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:49
the more I watch the contact-oriented KBO, where 95 mph fastballs are comparatively rare, the more I believe it's the increasing pitch velocity that poses the bigger problem for MLB's aesthetic quality. I was pretty down on the idea of moving the pitching distance back when the idea was floating around last year, but now I wonder if it makes more sense.
Sam
2:49
Idea for honoring Marvin Miller: have Andy Messersmith give the speech
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:49
He's definitely a player worth considering, if he's willing to take part.
Travis
2:50
Re: relief pitcher HoF rankings. As you've mentioned in several of your articles, WAR rankings might not be the most accurate/insightful for evaluating a primary relief pitcher's HoF worthiness. Any insight as to a revised ranking based upon WPA/that hybrid measure you've used for Rivera/Hoffman/Wagner et al that can be readily accessible? (Probably a BR question more than a FG question). Also, while the primary case for him is as a reliever, any way to exclude Eckersley from that ranking? It seems as though he's an outlier in a way that drastically affects the standards.
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:52
That hybrid metric is indeed on the list of JAWS-related issues I'm hoping to address before the next election; I think it's worth considering. If you read my Wagner profile, note that in the table I break out the averages both with and without Eckersley https://blogs.fangraphs.com/jaws-and-the-2020-hall-of-fame-ballot-bill...
Guest
2:52
Why no discussion about lowering the mound?  We did it once and people are generally happy with the results.
AvatarJay Jaffe
2:53
Sorry, I didn't mean to exclude that from the comment above — it's worth considering, as is tweaking the strike zone, which like adjusting the height of the mound is also a change that has some historical precedents that are more recent than 1893, the last time the pitching distance changed.
Connecting…